Carlo_M
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Oct 31, 1997
- Messages
- 13,392
With 7 films and not enough time, I can't do a full review/comparison of all films. Also, I'm no longer able to because I've gifted my old BD copies to family, so now all I have in my possession are the 4K UHD versions via the Nolan Collection. I thought I'd start this thread to compile my thoughts as I am able to watch the films, and to give a place for members to do so as well. Again, these are just my quick thoughts on the 4K A/V transfers, not full reviews. And only for the films I've watched for now, I'll add posts as I'm able to view more discs.
The Dark Knight
I find it to be an improved transfer because I was one of those who was very sensitive to the EE/ringing on the IMAX scenes on the former Blu-Ray transfer. I could not find a hint edge enhancement/ringing in those scenes in this transfer. Also I'm glad that since the DTS-HD Master soundtrack is the only English soundtrack, the disc doesn't default to lossy Dolby Digital like the original BD did (IIRC, I had to be conscious to change it to the lossless track every time I started up the old BD).
The Dark Knight Rises
Another five-star A/V transfer. Here's one thing I'm noticing (and again, apologies that I can't A/B due to the original BDs being given away to family). I think Bane is much easier to understand. I think (but have no proof) they upped the volume on his voice. Because I remember always straining to understand what he was saying on the old BD (in fact I turned on the subtitles). But on this new disc, I have no need for the subs. And it's not a matter of "well now you've heard/read it so you know what you're listening for". I watched the original BD many times and always had difficulty understanding him, not so on this transfer.
I'd be curious if anyone else noticed what I've pointed out above, specifically about the EE (or lack of it) and Bane's dialogue. If you still have the original BDs, I'd love to hear your thoughts on any A/B comparison you may perform.
Current review setup: Oppo 203 -> Samsung KS8000 65" 4K TV
EDIT: The upgrade to 4K really makes the IMAX shots look amazing. They looked good on the BDs, but you can really tell there is a resolution upgrade in these UHD discs.
The Dark Knight
I find it to be an improved transfer because I was one of those who was very sensitive to the EE/ringing on the IMAX scenes on the former Blu-Ray transfer. I could not find a hint edge enhancement/ringing in those scenes in this transfer. Also I'm glad that since the DTS-HD Master soundtrack is the only English soundtrack, the disc doesn't default to lossy Dolby Digital like the original BD did (IIRC, I had to be conscious to change it to the lossless track every time I started up the old BD).
The Dark Knight Rises
Another five-star A/V transfer. Here's one thing I'm noticing (and again, apologies that I can't A/B due to the original BDs being given away to family). I think Bane is much easier to understand. I think (but have no proof) they upped the volume on his voice. Because I remember always straining to understand what he was saying on the old BD (in fact I turned on the subtitles). But on this new disc, I have no need for the subs. And it's not a matter of "well now you've heard/read it so you know what you're listening for". I watched the original BD many times and always had difficulty understanding him, not so on this transfer.
I'd be curious if anyone else noticed what I've pointed out above, specifically about the EE (or lack of it) and Bane's dialogue. If you still have the original BDs, I'd love to hear your thoughts on any A/B comparison you may perform.
Current review setup: Oppo 203 -> Samsung KS8000 65" 4K TV
EDIT: The upgrade to 4K really makes the IMAX shots look amazing. They looked good on the BDs, but you can really tell there is a resolution upgrade in these UHD discs.
Last edited:
