SFMike

Second Unit
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
455
Reaction score
516
Points
110
Real Name
Michael
For those that missed the limited Fathom Events sponsored showings of Peter Jackson's WWI documentary They Shall Not Grow Old, it looks like Warner Brothers will be putting into larger release this spring. This is a must see film and a great achievement for Peter Jackson. Here is a good review. https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/12/they-shall-not-grow-old-movie-of-the-year/ One of the amazing aspects of it is the excellent 3D conversion done on most of the film to make it even more immediate to viewers. Peter Jackson has said that this is the preferred way of viewing his film and I would totally agree. When Warner Brothers gives the US a Blu-ray release I hope that they will be kind enough to provide the 3D option on the Blu-ray release. Sadly the Blu-ray of this film released in the UK was only 2D so if Warner Home Video doesn't come through we will have on home 3D version to enjoy. I wish there was someway to reach Warner Home Video to persuade them of the importance of this but have little hope. See this film on the big screen and in 3D if you can as it is worth the time and effort.
 

Dick

Lead Actor
Premium
Joined
May 22, 1999
Messages
8,420
Reaction score
5,137
Points
9,110
Real Name
Rick
This lack of support for 3D on physical media makes me want to hurl...on the CEO's of the companies responsible. Hey, idiots, many of us have invested thousands of dollars on this technology, and 3D films continue to be released to theaters. Get with it, you greedy pricks.
 

SFMike

Second Unit
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
455
Reaction score
516
Points
110
Real Name
Michael
This lack of support for 3D on physical media makes me want to hurl...on the CEO's of the companies responsible. Hey, idiots, many of us have invested thousands of dollars on this technology, and 3D films continue to be released to theaters. Get with it, you greedy pricks.
We've been given 4K in TVs and media as an exchange and are forced to live with it. Customer satisfaction is so 20th century.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MatthewA

theonemacduff

Second Unit
Joined
Nov 10, 2010
Messages
419
Reaction score
136
Points
110
Location
the wet coast
Real Name
Jon Paul
Saw it in a special showing on the 17th. When the film switches from B&W to colour and stereo widescreen the effect is astonishing, as if you had just left history behind and were being dumped into the trenches, with horse-drawn artillery going by in the background of the shot, and people talking and moving in the foreground, and the noises of harnesses and wheels. Just amazing. I would like to see it again in a theatre, but apparently, there was only one additional showing, the 27th, and that's all for now folks. Plus, the showing had a thirty-minute "Making Of" after the show, which most people stayed to see. I too, hope that they release it in 3D.
 

Interdimensional

Second Unit
Joined
Mar 21, 2015
Messages
472
Reaction score
893
Points
110
Real Name
Ed
I'd love to get this one on 3D-Bluray. They have the file, it's just a matter of putting it on a shiny disc and letting us give them our money!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SFMike

JQuintana

Banned
BANNED
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
1,194
Reaction score
551
Points
1,610
Real Name
Me
This lack of support for 3D on physical media makes me want to hurl...on the CEO's of the companies responsible. Hey, idiots, many of us have invested thousands of dollars on this technology, and 3D films continue to be released to theaters. Get with it, you greedy pricks.
Buying into 3D was a gamble and many lost. CEO's of these companies saw the writing on the wall in that it wasn't a money maker. It was poorly implemented as well. So it doesn't make sense to invest more money in a failed niche format for home. They may make a decent profit off the theater runs but that's about it.

Oh and calling them idiots probably isn't helping your cause, that is assuming you think they are here reading the 3D posts. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Conrad_SSS and nara

Interdimensional

Second Unit
Joined
Mar 21, 2015
Messages
472
Reaction score
893
Points
110
Real Name
Ed
I don't demand the release of 3D blurays to justify the money I spent on the technology. I find I simply enjoy the film better that way. I respect other people's preferences, but there are many 2d options on the market, and 3D offers something special.

It's just a matter of putting the film they made on a disc and offering it to the paying customer. Even if demand is not huge they should be able to find a way to produce a small run and make it available. That's the way forward for physical media in general.
 

Dick

Lead Actor
Premium
Joined
May 22, 1999
Messages
8,420
Reaction score
5,137
Points
9,110
Real Name
Rick
Oh and calling them idiots probably isn't helping your cause, that is assuming you think they are here reading the 3D posts. ;)
Probably not. Knee-jerk reaction, but that's the way I feel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SFMike

SFMike

Second Unit
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
455
Reaction score
516
Points
110
Real Name
Michael
Oh and calling them idiots probably isn't helping your cause, that is assuming you think they are here reading the 3D posts. ;)
From my many years of pleading and complaining about the lack of customer service or the complete disappearance of customer satisfaction in the tech industry I've come to the conclusion the studios and tech companies do not read posts and could care less what the unwashed masses want or think. The new 8K TVs are a great example of the industry telling us what we want when all I want is a 4K 3D capable monitor and that of course falls on deaf ears. In the corporate world those departments that dealt with customer satisfaction were downsized years ago to cut costs and now are only given lip service in PR brochures and at public events. 3D Blu-ray releases from the studios are a great example of this corporate disregard for consumers. Has there ever been an actual strategy for 3D Blu-ray releases even from the beginning? Disney is a prime example with a Blu-ray 3D release here and there, and then maybe a special deal with this retailer or that or maybe no release in the US at all. But always make sure the 3D disc is priced exorbitantly and in multidisc packaging. We were never told what the strategy was or is and requests for information are NEVER provided. Universal should be heartily congratulated for replacing quickly the mis-authored Revenge Of The Creature 3D disc last year. So nice to see a corporation fix a mistake and make customers happy no matter how small that consumer base may be. So even if I believe someone from a tech or entertainment corporation is reading this I am secure in the knowledge my opinion will not rise any further on the corporate feeding chain as all decisions come from the insulated top and only take profit into consideration and people who still enjoy 3D at home or at the theater are no longer seen as a healthy profit point and are therefore nonentities to the current business plan. The only thing now is to see how quickly they can end 3D quietly without embarrassment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mark Cappelletty

Bill McCamy

Second Unit
Joined
Jan 1, 1999
Messages
357
Reaction score
98
Points
110
Real Name
Gasim de Paris
I was put off by the name-calling and desire to vomit on corporate decision makers with whom you disagreed. Point is, many of us had no desire to pay extra for 3D displays, goggles for the home and unpleasant affects we found viewing 3D in theaters. The anger expressed over the discontinuance of a niche format seems unreasonable. If 3D stayed, I wouldn't be angry about it. I'm not gleeful that is going. However, I think 4K on an OLED display 2D is remarkable and I do not bemoan the absence of 3D on new 4K displays.
 
Last edited:

TJPC

Producer
Joined
Jul 15, 2016
Messages
3,726
Reaction score
3,231
Points
4,110
Age
68
Location
Hamilton Ontario
Real Name
Terry Carroll
I was put off by the name-calling and desire to vomit on corporate decision makers with whom you disagreed. Point is, many of us had no desire to pay extra for 3D displays, goggles for the home and unpleasant affects we found viewing 3D in theaters. The anger expressed over the discontinuance of a niche format seems unreasonable. If 3D stayed, I wouldn't be angry about it. I'm not gleeful that is going. However, I think 4K on an OLED display 2D is remarkable and I do not bemoan the absence of 3D on new 4K displays.
Do you not think 4K is just another niche format?
 

Bill McCamy

Second Unit
Joined
Jan 1, 1999
Messages
357
Reaction score
98
Points
110
Real Name
Gasim de Paris
Do you not think 4K is just another niche format?
It may be. However, it is difficult to buy a display that is not 4K now. Market penetration and public acceptance seems greater than niche. Streaming is making optical discs niche unfortunately, but 4K seems to be growing. If in decade only HD is offered, we'll know 4K was like 3D.
 

SFMike

Second Unit
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
455
Reaction score
516
Points
110
Real Name
Michael
I was put off by the name-calling and desire to vomit on corporate decision makers with whom you disagreed. Point is, many of us had no desire to pay extra for 3D displays, goggles for the home and unpleasant affects we found viewing 3D in theaters. The anger expressed over the discontinuance of a niche format seems unreasonable. If 3D stayed, I wouldn't be angry about it. I'm not gleeful that is going. However, I think 4K on an OLED display 2D is remarkable and I do not bemoan the absence of 3D on new 4K displays.
I always amazes me then when 3D haters feel compelled to post in a discussion of people that enjoy and support 3D tech. Your superiority in thinking 3D a gimmick and your magnanimity in stating you would not "be angry" if 3D TVs were still produced and that you are "not gleeful" it's going is truly off putting. Also since you don't care if 3D is an option on 4K displays and no one is forcing you to use it if it is then I don't see the point in sharing your opinion except to broadcast your feeling of superiority over those who have invested and enjoy 3D technology. Anyway I started this thread to be about the film They Shall Not Grow Old. You've made your point goodbye.
 

Dick

Lead Actor
Premium
Joined
May 22, 1999
Messages
8,420
Reaction score
5,137
Points
9,110
Real Name
Rick
I was put off by the name-calling and desire to vomit on corporate decision makers with whom you disagreed. Point is, many of us had no desire to pay extra for 3D displays, goggles for the home and unpleasant affects we found viewing 3D in theaters. The anger expressed over the discontinuance of a niche format seems unreasonable. If 3D stayed, I wouldn't be angry about it. I'm not gleeful that is going. However, I think 4K on an OLED display 2D is remarkable and I do not bemoan the absence of 3D on new 4K displays.
I have invested roughly $5000 on my 200 3D Blu-rays, plus $2500 on my 65" 3D OLED display and nearly as much on my previous Panny plasma with active glasses, plus $500 for my several 3D players. Are you saying that my $10,000 expenditure for this format that all the studios were promoting to the hilt not five years ago was a silly sidetrack? I love 3D, as do hundreds on this forum. I feel betrayed and abandoned by the studios (especially you, Disney, who were instrumental in getting me into 3D in the first place). I am sick of hearing all this bullshit about business decisions. I get it. Corporations are all about greed for their stockholders and to hell with the consumers who helped them get where they are. But leaving probably a million or so (?) loyal 3D purchasers wondering what they are going to do when their current display goes bad is simply an example of CEO's shitting on the rest of us.
 

Interdimensional

Second Unit
Joined
Mar 21, 2015
Messages
472
Reaction score
893
Points
110
Real Name
Ed
I don't see how it would be 'greed', it's just general indifference and risk aversion. I feel there is a continuing niche there that they can sustain and profit from if they paid attention to 3D.

My guess is that there would have been some titles in the past that were overproduced and didn't sell as well as anticipated, so rather than accept that they got it wrong and misjudged the demand, it might be easier to just go along with the '3D is dead' narrative and blame it on that. There is money to be made releasing 3D, but sometimes on a smaller scale than some of the larger companies are used to catering to. Labels like Twilight Time and Kino are more in touch and responsive to niches like that, but to the likes of Disney and Paramount, perhaps they have higher overhead, perhaps they are oblivious, perhaps they are just bastards, but for giant multinational organisations with many other concerns it is all too often ignored.

Doesn't have to be like that.
 

JQuintana

Banned
BANNED
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
1,194
Reaction score
551
Points
1,610
Real Name
Me
Do you not think 4K is just another niche format?
I would say no, not just no, heck no. Look at the sheer number of 4K displays being sold hourly in this country at all the big box stores. It's far exceeded the niche 3D display sales probably in a much shorter span of time as well. With 3D, you had to seek the TV out at the stores. Today (well over last 1-2 years) all that you can buy is pretty much 100% 4K in some form. All at many many price points. Couldn't say that with the 3D stuff.

3D was always niche and that's part of why it died.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bill McCamy

JQuintana

Banned
BANNED
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
1,194
Reaction score
551
Points
1,610
Real Name
Me
I have invested roughly $5000 on my 200 3D Blu-rays, plus $2500 on my 65" 3D OLED display and nearly as much on my previous Panny plasma with active glasses, plus $500 for my several 3D players. Are you saying that my $10,000 expenditure for this format that all the studios were promoting to the hilt not five years ago was a silly sidetrack? I love 3D, as do hundreds on this forum. I feel betrayed and abandoned by the studios (especially you, Disney, who were instrumental in getting me into 3D in the first place). I am sick of hearing all this bullshit about business decisions. I get it. Corporations are all about greed for their stockholders and to hell with the consumers who helped them get where they are. But leaving probably a million or so (?) loyal 3D purchasers wondering what they are going to do when their current display goes bad is simply an example of CEO's shitting on the rest of us.

Sorry to hear you may struggle to watch your 3D if your set(s) die but you and I know you were 100% gambling on the format from day one. You honestly didn't think it would become the norm for all TV viewing and buying did you? Looking at the history of 3D over all these decades we all knew every time it popped up, pardon the pun, it ended up being a flash in the pan every single time. It happened in the 50's, 60's, 70's, 80's. All those eras were short lived, nothing stuck around full time. TV makers never really jumped in during those eras because they new it was a losing proposition.

Manufacturers honestly couldn't care less what you or the other 3D at home fans spent, they aren't obligated to keep feeding your hobby for your entire life. They saw it dying and left the market just like millions and millions of other products.

But as pointed out this is about a wonderful movie and it's nice that it was offered in 3D at the theaters at least.
 

Sam Posten

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Oct 30, 1997
Messages
28,257
Reaction score
5,197
Points
9,110
Location
Aberdeen, MD & Navesink, NJ
Website
www.navesink.net
Real Name
Sam Posten
I always amazes me then when 3D haters feel compelled to post in a discussion of people that enjoy and support 3D tech.

Agreed completely. Posters are certainly welcome to post "I hope this comes to the home in 3d", but we've got a million threads where they can bitch about the death of consumer level 3d. Further comments about that will be moved or deleted
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stephen_J_H

Dick

Lead Actor
Premium
Joined
May 22, 1999
Messages
8,420
Reaction score
5,137
Points
9,110
Real Name
Rick
Sorry to hear you may struggle to watch your 3D if your set(s) die but you and I know you were 100% gambling on the format from day one. You honestly didn't think it would become the norm for all TV viewing and buying did you?
Sorry to hear you may struggle to watch your 3D if your set(s) die but you and I know you were 100% gambling on the format from day one. You honestly didn't think it would become the norm for all TV viewing and buying did you? Looking at the history of 3D over all these decades we all knew every time it popped up, pardon the pun, it ended up being a flash in the pan every single time. It happened in the 50's, 60's, 70's, 80's. All those eras were short lived, nothing stuck around full time. TV makers never really jumped in during those eras because they new it was a losing proposition.

Manufacturers honestly couldn't care less what you or the other 3D at home fans spent, they aren't obligated to keep feeding your hobby for your entire life. They saw it dying and left the market just like millions and millions of other products.

But as pointed out this is about a wonderful movie and it's nice that it was offered in 3D at the theaters at least.
Yes, it seemed (to me) like 3D was here to stay, after several abortive attempts. Had I had even a strong suspicion this format would rather abruptly be discontinued/not supported, I don't think I'd have gone all-in as I did. I am not independently wealthy. And only a few of us had the opportunity to see THEY SHALL NOT GROW OLD at all, let alone in 3D.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stephen_J_H

JQuintana

Banned
BANNED
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
1,194
Reaction score
551
Points
1,610
Real Name
Me
I guess we can agree to disagree.

When 3D hit the TV world my first thought was basically, "this will never last" and as they kept bungling things over those handful of years it was clear they were on a downward spiral. Too many issues, costs were out of line, two different formats fighting each other. It was easy to see very early on that we as customers were gambling away our money if we invested in 3D at home. The writing was on the wall from day one.
 

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

Threads
343,694
Messages
4,687,123
Members
140,996
Latest member
tominsantafe