I recently purchased an HD ready set with only component inputs for HD. I may have missed something, but the petition doesn't seem to address the concern that an HD-DVD player may not output full resolution via analog component outputs. This would seem to be an important concern in light of the large number of non-DVI/HDCP capable HD ready sets already in the hands of users.
Copyprotection, Hollin's Bill, Fair use .... is a much broader subject and more complex than we wanted to deal with in this petition. In general, I think they should spend money enforcing the laws against real pirates, than punishing consumers. Ultimately it is the consumer who feeds them, and it is the consumer who yields the power.