Lou Sytsma
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Nov 1, 1998
- Messages
- 6,103
- Real Name
- Lou Sytsma
Yes, the movie is very faithful to the novella - except for the ending.
King went on record saying he preferred Darabont's ending to his own.
I sure do have to disagree with your spoiler comment about Carmody.
I ascribe the tragic ending to the fact that sometimes, many times, life is not fair. I grew up on the monster flicks in the 50's when the scientists always figured it out in the end and everybody lived happily ever after, so the ending was hard to accept.
I've just watched the movie and liked it a lot, but Mrs. Carmody really got on my nerves, a lot. I find the tale it told to be very topical and relevant to today. Won't say more to stay within the rules.
One thing to keep in mind is that even before Thomas Jane's character does what he does, the miliatary is already advancing. It was timing, tragic timing, that's all it was. IMHO, of course.Well guess it's open for interpretation, but I think I do recall Darabont addressing the assessment I provided (kind of coyly said something like "was she right?")
As far as you're other thoughts, I do believe you can talk about political themes strictly as they pertain to the film. But if you intend to comment on a certain prominent political figure, as I suspect, I would agree there's no way that's not a powderkeg.
One thing to keep in mind is that even before Thomas Jane's character does what he does, the miliatary is already advancing. It was timing, tragic timing, that's all it was. IMHO, of course.
Like illogic? To be truthful I am incapable of accepting Carmody's ideas.Yes, yes. But you're thinking of it logically. If the twist I proposed is to be accepted, it means other forces are at play.
Like illogic? To be truthful I am incapable of accepting Carmody's ideas.
And, I recently watched the b&w version for the first time. Wow. You wouldn't think the film would really "work" in b&w due to the sci-fi/horror element(s) & the effects, etc. However, I find this particular version to be extremely effective. Seeing this film without color really adds to the creepy ambience & gives the movie a neo-noir vibe/tone that the color version doesn't have....as much. I don't think b&w would really work for a lot of other modern sci-fi/horror films, but it definitely worked extremely well re: TM.
Even though I read the SK short story that this film is based on & understand the criticism re: the change in the storyline - I do find the ending appropriately nihilistic....especially considering what the characters thought was going to happen to them. And, IMHO the fact that it appeared they would have been saved minutes later doesn't change that.
This Stephen King Classic Has a Surprising Connection to The Walking Dead
Anyone who's seen the 2007 movie The Mist and The Walking Dead might recognize a few familiar faces thanks to Frank Darabont reusing actors.www.cbr.com