UHD Review The Last Picture Show (Columbia Classics 4K Ultra HD Collection, Vol 3) UHD Review (1 Viewer)

[uncledougie]

I don’t think this is correct. I have RCA’s original laserdisc with the 4:3 image, and the subsequent releases appear to be a normal 1.85:1 image from an open-matte source.

In the DVD Definitive Director’s Cut the pool scene is cropped and not as originally shown theatrically. The same was true in the widescreen laserdisc I’m sure (a lady bought some of my discs years ago and that was one of them). I’m not clear what other changes were made since there are evidently three cuts, but only the first and third are available on the latest release. This one particular reframing is not addressed in the Movie-Censorship descriptions. There may be others unaddressed, no way of knowing.

 

[Will Krupp]

“That shot” was fully revealing in the original theatrical showing ratio (1.85:1), but later zoomed and/or cropped, and I remember reading about other potential minor changes, but it’s been long enough ago I can’t recall the exact source.

See, that's very interesting, thank you. I was only four years old when it was first released so I never saw it until years later on VHS (eye opening, to say the least.) When I first saw the "widescreen" version on DVD, I had just assumed that Gary's dingle disappeared within the normal widescreen cropping (and was sore disappointed, by the way!) Interesting to know that decisions were made. In any event, it certainly doesn't spoil the movie and this transfer is really really lovely.

By the way, I don't think I really need the Theatrical cut for any purpose (and the way it's stacked over the blu-ray is just irritating and gets in my way) so anybody who would like it is welcome to it, just so long as you understand it won't be in the original box. Let me know and it's yours.

 

[compson]

In the DVD Definitive Director’s Cut the pool scene is cropped and not as originally shown theatrically. The same was true in the widescreen laserdisc I’m sure (a lady bought some of my discs years ago and that was one of them). I’m not clear what other changes were made since there are evidently three cuts, but only the first and third are available on the latest release. This one particular reframing is not addressed in the Movie-Censorship descriptions. There may be others unaddressed, no way of knowing.

As you know, every open-matte image is cropped in projection. I don’t think I have the standard DVD, but the Criterion Blu-ray and this new release appear to show a standard 1.85:1 image as would be projected theatrically. I assume you could raise the center point for a 1:85 home video release to avoid showing something in the bottom of the image if you wished, but that doesn’t appear to have occurred here. I say that based on what I see on the laserdisc, which is definitely revealing.

 

[uncledougie]

I saw it theatrically at 1.85:1 and the later 1.85 composition is not the same. It’s not of great importance but one wonders if any other reframing happened along the line in the newer transfers and versions.

 

[Will Krupp]

I saw it theatrically at 1.85:1 and the later 1.85 composition is not the same.

I hope I'm not being indelicate but, once you see it, it's not something you're likely to forget.

 

[B-ROLL]

The big thing about the Criterion is its ONLY in the BBS box so you're paying for several other movies. Its also just the Director's Cut (at the request of Bogdanovich) and sourced from a third gen element (why the ONeg wasn't around when Sony did their restorations for that Criterion box I do not know).

Otherwise what's kept:

-2009 solo Peter Bogdanovich Audio Commentary

-"...A Look Back"

-"A Conversation with Peter Bogdanovich"

-Location Footage

-Trailers

What's dropped:

-1991 Criterion Laserdisc commentary

-"Picture This" (1990)

-Francois Truffaut Conversation

What's added:

-1972 Theatrical Cut (in 4k)

-1991 Reissue featurette

Yes but you get Head from the Criterion BBS Story blu-ray set !

 

[uncledougie]

I hope I'm not being indelicate but, once you see it, it's not something you're likely to forget.

I was 19 and impressionable and I saw just about everything mainstream to obscure that was released. What can I say? I can vividly recall the thrill of the roadshow 50s & 60s, and also the disappointment when I detected deletions seeing some of them years later like South Pacific, The Alamo, or general release versions of The Great Race, Camelot, Goodbye, Mr. Chips, where changes were made that ruined the flow and lost entire sequences and musical material. I’m sensitive to changes, in other words.

 

[battlebeast]

The big thing about the Criterion is its ONLY in the BBS box so you're paying for several other movies. Its also just the Director's Cut (at the request of Bogdanovich) and sourced from a third gen element (why the ONeg wasn't around when Sony did their restorations for that Criterion box I do not know).

Otherwise what's kept:

-2009 solo Peter Bogdanovich Audio Commentary

-"...A Look Back"

-"A Conversation with Peter Bogdanovich"

-Location Footage

-Trailers

What's dropped:

-1991 Criterion Laserdisc commentary

-"Picture This" (1990)

-Francois Truffaut Conversation

What's added:

-1972 Theatrical Cut (in 4k)

-1991 Reissue featurette

Thank you! Much obliged.

 

[Lord Dalek]

I guess you could also consider Drive, He Said and A Safe Place bonus features since its highly unlikely they'll ever surface outside of that box.

 

[Mark-P]

By the way, I don't think I really need the Theatrical cut for any purpose (and the way it's stacked over the blu-ray is just irritating and gets in my way) so anybody who would like it is welcome to it, just so long as you understand it won't be in the original box. Let me know and it's yours.

I don’t suppose you‘d be willing to part with the From Here to Eternity miniseries bonus disc? I’d love to be able to get my hands on that disc as I won’t spend $100 for a box set when I don’t even have a 4K disc player.

 

[Will Krupp]

I don’t suppose you‘d be willing to part with the From Here to Eternity miniseries bonus disc? I’d love to be able to get my hands on that disc as I won’t spend $100 for a box set when I don’t even have a 4K disc player.

I would, but that's one of the main reasons I bought the box set rather than waiting for single releases! I knew it was exclusive and not likely to be released on its own! I'm Sorry!

(and I got really mad at first because I couldn't find it. This is the first one of these I ever bought and I didn't realize it would be tucked in a little envelope inside the book!)

 

[Noel Aguirre]

Have the excellent Criterion already. No need for this- for me.

 

[Lord Dalek]

Yes but you get Head from the Criterion BBS Story blu-ray set !

According to Bob Raffelson that was literally the only reason why they titled the movie that. "From the People Who Gave You Head!"

 

[Lee Sandersen]

Yes, my copy has the same edits you describe. I wish people would leave films alone. Not that what they cut in this particular situation leaves me wanting, but it seems just plain wrong to alter a piece of art. Like painting a moustache on the Mona Lisa.

 

[Will Krupp]

Yes, my copy has the same edits you describe. I wish people would leave films alone. Not that what they cut in this particular situation leaves me wanting, but it seems just plain wrong to alter a piece of art. Like painting a moustache on the Mona Lisa.

I hear you, but it hits different when DaVinci paints that mustache himself, doesn't it?

 

[Robert Crawford]

Several posts have been removed because personal references towards others is sidetracking this review thread. Any further such posts will result in thread bans.

 

[Gary Dean Thomas]

See, that's very interesting, thank you. I was only four years old when it was first released so I never saw it until years later on VHS (eye opening, to say the least.) When I first saw the "widescreen" version on DVD, I had just assumed that Gary's dingle disappeared within the normal widescreen cropping (and was sore disappointed, by the way!) Interesting to know that decisions were made. In any event, it certainly doesn't spoil the movie and this transfer is really really lovely.

By the way, I don't think I really need the Theatrical cut for any purpose (and the way it's stacked over the blu-ray is just irritating and gets in my way) so anybody who would like it is welcome to it, just so long as you understand it won't be in the original box. Let me know and it's yours.

Do you still have the theatrical cut disc you offered to give away. I'm looking for a stand alone copy of The Last Picture Show 3 disc edition, but apparently it's still only available on the Columbia Classics Volume 3 collection, and I simply prefer not wasting my money on an expensive box set just to get one that I love.
Thank you!

 

[Will Krupp]

Do you still have the theatrical cut disc you offered to give away. I'm looking for a stand alone copy of The Last Picture Show 3 disc edition, but apparently it's still only available on the Columbia Classics Volume 3 collection, and I simply prefer not wasting my money on an expensive box set just to get one that I love.
Thank you!

I'm so sorry but I already gave it away to another HTF member!

 

[DarkVader]

Do you still have the theatrical cut disc you offered to give away. I'm looking for a stand alone copy of The Last Picture Show 3 disc edition, but apparently it's still only available on the Columbia Classics Volume 3 collection, and I simply prefer not wasting my money on an expensive box set just to get one that I love.
Thank you!

There's a ton available on eBay.