I've watched the film a couple of times. It's a corny melodrama for sure, but Jolson is fantastic in it and his songs can't be beat. that said, I doubt I'll be upgrading unless this hits a fantastic sale price. I'm pleased with the presentation of the original DVD set. This Bluray upgrade should of had his other films in the set that are currently MOD only instead of simply repacking the other discs. An HD upgrade of Mammy (restored in the Archives and the disc looks great) and Wonder Bar (needing more work based on the MOD-DVD) would of been an awesome set.