Guy Martin
Second Unit
- Joined
- Nov 29, 1998
- Messages
- 347
Okay, I realize this is one of the most famous movie questions of all time. But last night I decided to watch side B of the DVD, the prerelease version with some different scenes, most notably a scene at the District Attorney's office which supposedly explains who killed the chauffeur. If they did I didn't catch it. My only guess is
that since Marlowe's buddy tells the DA that you have two murders, both solved, in reference to the deaths of Geiger (who was killed by the chauffeur because the chauffeur was in love with Carmen and wanted to stop Geiger from blackmailing her) and Joe Brody (killed by Geiger's henchman who thought that Brody killed Geiger). This would indicate that they do not consider the chauffeur's death a murder, and thus the chauffeur, shaken from having murdered Geiger and distraught because he lost the photos (which Brody stole after clocking him (explaining the bruise on the chauffeur's head) merely killed himself by driving off the pier.
The only other theory, which is equally possible in both versions is simply that
Brody killed the chauffeur and was just lying to Marlowe when he said that he didn't.
Simple isn't it?
Any thoughts?
- Guy
that since Marlowe's buddy tells the DA that you have two murders, both solved, in reference to the deaths of Geiger (who was killed by the chauffeur because the chauffeur was in love with Carmen and wanted to stop Geiger from blackmailing her) and Joe Brody (killed by Geiger's henchman who thought that Brody killed Geiger). This would indicate that they do not consider the chauffeur's death a murder, and thus the chauffeur, shaken from having murdered Geiger and distraught because he lost the photos (which Brody stole after clocking him (explaining the bruise on the chauffeur's head) merely killed himself by driving off the pier.
The only other theory, which is equally possible in both versions is simply that
Brody killed the chauffeur and was just lying to Marlowe when he said that he didn't.
Simple isn't it?
Any thoughts?
- Guy