Paul_D
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2001
- Messages
- 2,048
I started watching this with EXTREMELY elevated expectations, after years of hearing how good it was. I popped the limited edition DVD release into my player, and cranked up the DTS mix, and prepared myself!
My final impressions were:
FOR
-First 30 minutes were really excellent
-Incredible sense of style - shot composition and color balance were both amazing - this is an essential film to watch on DVD
-Beautiful sets
-vicious and shocking early murder scene that really uncomfortable to watch - as it should be!
-jessica harper looks so innocent - which is sooooo essential for the role
AGAINST
-cheesy crapola ending - I know it didn't make sense, but I wouldn't have minded if it had matched the style or atmosphere of the early parts of the film
-the dubbing and acting (from everyone other than Jessica Harper) really bothered me - I know it was a convention of the time to record dialogue after filming, but its just so jarring if you're not used to it
-equally, I know that bad performances are as much a part of Italian horror movies as gallons of spilled blood, but it can sometimes be offputting
-I like some of the goblin soundtrack a lot, but hearing them praise their own work in the documentary REALLY put me off
Definately worth seeing, but I think I need to see some of Argento's other films to be able to put this one in context. I don't think it sits well as a film in its own right. But I can imagine that as part of Argento's body of work, its merits can be appreciated much more!
Quick question: The box lists it as 98 minutes long, and yet the tagline, quoted in the trailers but not on the box, is "The Only Thing More Terrifying Than The Last 12 Minutes Of This Film Are The First 92." It's advertised as UNCUT, so what happened to those other 6 minutes???
(edit: added an extra point for)
[Edited last by Paul Dalmaine on September 22, 2001 at 09:06 AM]
My final impressions were:
FOR
-First 30 minutes were really excellent
-Incredible sense of style - shot composition and color balance were both amazing - this is an essential film to watch on DVD
-Beautiful sets
-vicious and shocking early murder scene that really uncomfortable to watch - as it should be!
-jessica harper looks so innocent - which is sooooo essential for the role
AGAINST
-cheesy crapola ending - I know it didn't make sense, but I wouldn't have minded if it had matched the style or atmosphere of the early parts of the film
-the dubbing and acting (from everyone other than Jessica Harper) really bothered me - I know it was a convention of the time to record dialogue after filming, but its just so jarring if you're not used to it
-equally, I know that bad performances are as much a part of Italian horror movies as gallons of spilled blood, but it can sometimes be offputting
-I like some of the goblin soundtrack a lot, but hearing them praise their own work in the documentary REALLY put me off
Definately worth seeing, but I think I need to see some of Argento's other films to be able to put this one in context. I don't think it sits well as a film in its own right. But I can imagine that as part of Argento's body of work, its merits can be appreciated much more!
Quick question: The box lists it as 98 minutes long, and yet the tagline, quoted in the trailers but not on the box, is "The Only Thing More Terrifying Than The Last 12 Minutes Of This Film Are The First 92." It's advertised as UNCUT, so what happened to those other 6 minutes???
(edit: added an extra point for)
[Edited last by Paul Dalmaine on September 22, 2001 at 09:06 AM]