Ed Vandeweerd
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- May 9, 2000
- Messages
- 204
Hi All,
I picked up my copy of "From Here To Eternity" Superbit today. Until today I had never seen this Classic Film. I had waited with great anticipation for what in my mind should have been THE definitive version of the Film. 2003 marks the 50th Anniversary of this most treasured Classic. Superbit titles of the Past have had a much deserved reputation in both Superior Picture, Transfer & Sound. This was the Benchmarch on which Superbit and Columbia TriStar Prided itself. "From Here to Eternity" falls Far short of that Benchmark. I noticed a lot of Speckling on the Transfer throughout the film. This was definately not in keeping with the Standards of excellence for which Superbit has become known. I wonder if it might have been better to have had Mr Robert Harris do a complete restoration of the film before releasing it under the Superbit Banner? The DTS on this film is not vastly different from the Mono Track offered here either.
"Panic Room" also had it's Problems Firstly with Shoddy and Terrible Packaging and the fact that when loading the Audio that it defaults to is the dd 5.1 track Rather than the DTS track which had always been the case Previously. In my View Superbits should always be released in Keepcases with the customary Grey Superbit Packaging in keeping with the rest of it's titles. I've said my peice. Thoughts anyone?
Ed Vandeweerd
I picked up my copy of "From Here To Eternity" Superbit today. Until today I had never seen this Classic Film. I had waited with great anticipation for what in my mind should have been THE definitive version of the Film. 2003 marks the 50th Anniversary of this most treasured Classic. Superbit titles of the Past have had a much deserved reputation in both Superior Picture, Transfer & Sound. This was the Benchmarch on which Superbit and Columbia TriStar Prided itself. "From Here to Eternity" falls Far short of that Benchmark. I noticed a lot of Speckling on the Transfer throughout the film. This was definately not in keeping with the Standards of excellence for which Superbit has become known. I wonder if it might have been better to have had Mr Robert Harris do a complete restoration of the film before releasing it under the Superbit Banner? The DTS on this film is not vastly different from the Mono Track offered here either.
"Panic Room" also had it's Problems Firstly with Shoddy and Terrible Packaging and the fact that when loading the Audio that it defaults to is the dd 5.1 track Rather than the DTS track which had always been the case Previously. In my View Superbits should always be released in Keepcases with the customary Grey Superbit Packaging in keeping with the rest of it's titles. I've said my peice. Thoughts anyone?
Ed Vandeweerd