Star Wars contraversy (1 Viewer)

[Carl Mulder]

So I took a look a the new Attack of the clones disc, now most magazine reviewer's are giving the disc five stars,"ridiculas".
Im I being to picky or is the disc just riddled with artifacts, e.g the fireplace scene with anakin and padme.
"Just awful, awful.
Ice age on the other hand isn't a totally flawless dvd, but at least that breaks new ground, i.e incredible detail.
"some of the sharpest dvd video Ive ever seen.
So whats happened to Star Wars?
George lucas should be supervising every detail of his releases.
As far as I'm concerned, Stars should be nothing short of stunning, but george lucas does love all that lovely money and the fans don't matter anymore.

FEEDBACK PLEASE.

 

[Patrick McCart]

Your TV might not be set up right. Pretty much every review has given the disc a perfect score for video.

 

[Jeff Kleist]

It isn't artifacts

It's CCD video noise, just like you get with consumer camcorders on low-light areas

 

[Peter Apruzzese]

Im I being to picky or is the disc just riddled with artifacts, e.g the fireplace scene with anakin and padme.

That's what the theatrical prints (DLP and 35mm)looked like also, so it's NOT the fault of the DVD.

 

[Carl Mulder]

so what are the blocks im seeing.
does george lucas know about?
I never seen it on DLP?

 

[Dan Hitchman]

Lucas should face the music and finally realize that digital video is NOT 35mm film (nor even a tiny bit close to 70mm or Maxivision 48 fps), nor will it be for the forseeable future (Spielberg needs to slap his friend upside the head and snap him back to reality).

It's not perfected yet; not enough to be used in a major feature film.

The problems with the transfer are problems inherent with this generation of digital video technology used for shooting some movies and TV shows.

Dan

 

[SteveMo]

They want to use digital (at present time) to simplify the digital effects and DVD production process but at the cost of loosing low light quality images, and pixalation in theaters?

First I head there was no EE and that had me really excited, but then I saw a picture on avs of a screenshot called AOTC EE. So which is it EE or no EE?

 

[SteveMo]

I will try asking in a AOTC discussion thread.