- Joined
- May 9, 2002
- Messages
- 13,058
- Real Name
- Cameron Yee
I watched A New Hope and Rogue One a couple days after I finished Andor. And now I'm watching Andor again.
I was wondering whether Cassian was going to use his knowledge about Narkina 5 to bargain for his life (or even have given some of the information to B2EMO to play at the funeral), but it didn't come up. Just offering to go all in with the rebellion was good enough.
Meh. Luthen was trying to recruit Cassian from the very first time he met him. He didn't need any motivation from Maarva.I sort of feel like Luthen recognized that Cassian had evolved beyond his mercenary instincts which he saw early in the season and that he had been changed by his experiences. He (Cassian) was no longer operating in terms of self interest.
I'd also like to think that Maarva's speech made Luthen realize that he wasn't fighting his war alone which may have made him more conducive to taking Cassian into the movement.
Finally, a fellow like Luthen has to be pretty adept at sizing folks up, given his line of work.
- Walter.
But by the finale, he was on Ferrix to kill Cassian as a loose end. I think Walter's point was he may have been swayed back to his original interest to recruit him based on Maarva's speech and the uprising by Ferrix in general.
Good point, too.It may have been in the back of Luthen's mind, but it was never explicitly stated in season one. His only interest in Cassian was for the heist, not the rebellion.
I will rewatch E3. My recollection is that Luthen went there as much to get the part as to meet Andor. I didn't get the impression it was for mercenary recruitment, but recruitment in general. He ends up paying him because its the only way he could get him to do the job. At that point Andor is a loner not looking to join a cause.When Luthen spoke with Vel on Ferrix, he discussed his plan to eliminate Cassian with her, not to recruit him. I am not saying that Maarva's speech was the sole factor in his reversal, but I do believe based on his facial expressions while listening to the speech and later surveying the uprising that this made him realize that things were in motion.
Cassian's meeting with him at the Fondor was a much bigger factor in his reversal of course, for reasons I mentioned in my prior post. Up until that point, Luthen had never expressed interest in recruiting him. Even when he introduced Cassian to Vel's team prior to the heist, he told Vel that because he was a mercenary they could get rid of him (paraphrasing.)
It may have been in the back of Luthen's mind, but it was never explicitly stated in season one. His only interest in Cassian was for the heist, not the rebellion.
- Walter.
The first three episodes are the weakest ones but I imagine that episodes 4, 5 and 6 will capture your interest.I finally am able to start watching this show.
Been away from home for a few month and home now with the big tv and sound system.
Watched the first episode today.
It didn’t reel me in yet.
Can’t say I know what even happened in this episode.
He is looking for someone (sister?) and killed a couple of guys who tried to shake him down and a few flashbacks to when he was a kid.
Welp on to ep 2.
I think I've said it here before but before the show started, I wondered why they were putting up three episodes at once and after I saw them, I understood that spreading those episodes over three weeks would have felt pretty slow to the audience.The first three are fine if you treat them as a three-parter. But seriously, they should have just edited them as one long episode or "pilot movie," although them releasing them all at once is a sign they wanted people to watch them back-to-back.
Awesome episode.
Something that I had not thought of beforehand, but started to creep into my mind as the episode went on, was that the indigenous Dhani group would start their own secret revolt and screw up all the plans of the rebels. Turned out not to be the case, but there was great tension set up there.
The Eye was amazing looking.