Jason_V
Senior HTF Member
The (now-superseded by Picard) post-Nemesis novels actually did indeed have Jean-Luc and Beverly finally tying the knot and having a son together, which took place against the backdrop of the massive Borg-invasion in David Mack's Star Trek: Destiny trilogy (which happens roughly when Lower Decks now occurs in the screen-canon). The shows have sometimes shown a willingness to pick up plot-elements from the books and use them for their own storytelling, so this could in fact be a possible reason for Picard and Dr. Crusher's eventual estrangement.
100%, this plot thread could be picked up and made official. But if they did, setting aside the great math and arguments Adam set up, I want to SEE their relationship, what happened to bring them together and tear them apart. I want to SEE Jean-Luc theoretically walking out on his family or forgetting about that piece of his life. Since Season 4 of TNG, Picard has been about "family." He went to great lengths to protect a man he thought was his son in TNG: "Bloodlines." He had a complete breakdown when his brother and nephew died and he figured out he was the last Picard in Generations.
I also don't see Beverly keeping this information from him. I wouldn't put it past these writers to screw up her character that way based on Seasons 1 and 2, but I would hope McFadden and Stewart would step up and say "nuh, uh...this is no good."