Joey Prats
Auditioning
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2004
- Messages
- 2
Dear friends in the Star Trek (and DVD) Community,
I just have one sentiment regarding the packaging of the Star Trek feature films (Director's Edition and Special Collector's Edition) on DVD: They are so INCONSISTENT. I think Paramount needs to know how disappointed a lot of us are about these small inconsistencies. I wrote Paramount a letter regarding this concern. Here's an excerpt:
General Fan Comments and Suggestions:
·Why were Star Trek 3, 4, 5, and 6 released as Special
Collector’s Editions and not Director’s Editions, like
Star Trek 1 and 2. As collectors, we highly value the
Director’s Edition DVDs, simply because the films are put
together the way the directors intended them to be seen.
It would have been better if all the films just had one
uniform edition, either DE or CE.
·The studio should standardize the Star Trek feature film
series’ release on DVD. They should ALL be called either
Director’s Edition or Special Collector’s Edition, and not
a mixture of the two terminologies. I agree. It would look
better when the films are all displayed side by side. It
would give the feature films more cohesion and unity. The
packaging should also be standardized. At this point, Star
Trek 1 basically has a gold packaging, Star Trek 2 to 6
has a gray / silver packaging.
·The studio is becoming negligent in terms of putting
together these films on DVD. From the terminologies used
to the artwork of the DVDs. A good example would be the
general complaint on Star Trek VI, Disc 2, where the
excelsior is printed upside down. Also, in the Star Trek
Nemesis DVD’s inside sleeve, Captain Picard is shown
wearing the uniform he wore on the television series, not
the movies! Not to mention the picture of Captain Kirk
from Star Trek 3 appearing on the back cover of Star Trek
2. The fans are really upset by this.
If you ask me, Paramount got to a great start with Star Trek: The Motion Picture. They should revise Star Trek 2 to 6 to create a more unified look for the collection. If they patterned all the films after ST:TMP with its gold spine, I think it will make the collection look terrific.
Joey
I just have one sentiment regarding the packaging of the Star Trek feature films (Director's Edition and Special Collector's Edition) on DVD: They are so INCONSISTENT. I think Paramount needs to know how disappointed a lot of us are about these small inconsistencies. I wrote Paramount a letter regarding this concern. Here's an excerpt:
General Fan Comments and Suggestions:
·Why were Star Trek 3, 4, 5, and 6 released as Special
Collector’s Editions and not Director’s Editions, like
Star Trek 1 and 2. As collectors, we highly value the
Director’s Edition DVDs, simply because the films are put
together the way the directors intended them to be seen.
It would have been better if all the films just had one
uniform edition, either DE or CE.
·The studio should standardize the Star Trek feature film
series’ release on DVD. They should ALL be called either
Director’s Edition or Special Collector’s Edition, and not
a mixture of the two terminologies. I agree. It would look
better when the films are all displayed side by side. It
would give the feature films more cohesion and unity. The
packaging should also be standardized. At this point, Star
Trek 1 basically has a gold packaging, Star Trek 2 to 6
has a gray / silver packaging.
·The studio is becoming negligent in terms of putting
together these films on DVD. From the terminologies used
to the artwork of the DVDs. A good example would be the
general complaint on Star Trek VI, Disc 2, where the
excelsior is printed upside down. Also, in the Star Trek
Nemesis DVD’s inside sleeve, Captain Picard is shown
wearing the uniform he wore on the television series, not
the movies! Not to mention the picture of Captain Kirk
from Star Trek 3 appearing on the back cover of Star Trek
2. The fans are really upset by this.
If you ask me, Paramount got to a great start with Star Trek: The Motion Picture. They should revise Star Trek 2 to 6 to create a more unified look for the collection. If they patterned all the films after ST:TMP with its gold spine, I think it will make the collection look terrific.
Joey