Mike Knapp
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Aug 4, 1997
- Messages
- 644
- Real Name
- Mike
I have been working on this essay for many months. Putting it away when I didnt feel like dealing with it and then after the events in September I put it on a kind of hiatus. I decided it would be good for me to finish it up and post it now, in the spirit of helping others get what they can from their systems. There are three parts...Audio, Video and Accessories. Look for the other two parts soon, they are still being worked on. I really hope this helps some of you derive the same pleasure I get from this hobby,
Mike Knapp
After being involved in this hobby for many years I have come up with quite a few tweaks that you can perform on your system to get the maximum performance from it. Many of them are just common sense and many of them are free or so cheap they may as well be.
Some of them will cost some money and you may need to decide if the benefits warrant the expenditure in your situation. So here goes….How to squeeze the best performance from your Home Theater System.
First lets look at the audio portion. In order to have a good surround sound field you must first have a good two-channel sound-field. If your two-channel front sound-field is flat sounding, so will be your film sound-field. Developing a good stereo sound is not an easy task, but the benefits of your labor will bear sweet fruit even in home theater use.
TIPS: Basic Speaker placement
1) Keep your speakers as far away from other surfaces as possible. Don’t place them right next to the wall or the TV or right beside a sofa. Let them have their space. The space behind the speaker is almost as important as the space in front of it. Keep your speakers off the back wall as much as you can get away with and make sure the fronts of the speakers are well in front of the display device. (disregard for FPTV’s with perf screens)
2) NEVER place your speakers inside an entertainment center cabinet. This is a common occurrence, especially with the center channel speaker. Avoid this at all costs. If you absolutely must do this be sure to treat the cavity in which the speaker rests with acoustic materials such as foam or fiber-fill.
3) If your center channel speaker sits atop your TV (very common) be sure it is angled down toward the seating position and make sure the front of the speaker is beyond the front of the TV as far as possible. To achieve the proper angle you might use a rubber wedge shaped doorstop and some blu-tac (sticky rubber sold at art supply stores) to make sure the speaker stays in place or there are some commercially available stands to aid you in this.
4) Make sure your speakers match. They should all be identical but that is often not possible. If you cant use the exact same speakers for your surround system, try getting them all from the same manufacturer with the same drivers in them.
5) Eliminate first order reflections as best you can. Sit in your listening position and have a friend walk down the side-walls of your room with a mirror against the wall at your eye level. When you can see your speaker, that is the place on the wall that needs to be treated to reduce first order reflections.
TIPS: Sub-woofers
1) There will be some contention in this area but what I will describe is what I have used and what has worked for me. First thing is to make sure the sub is the same db level as the other speakers. This will yield you the most accurate results. You may prefer more bass than this will afford you but try this first for a while before goosing the LFE. A well-balanced sound system will sound smoother and more natural.
2) Placement…this is a can of worms to say the least. What has worked for me is the “reverse engineering” method. Place the sub-woofer in your seating position (remove the chair/couch) and put on a thumping soundtrack of some kind or play a sub-woofer test tone loop. Walk around the room and place your head at about the same height it will be when you are listening to your system. When the bass sounds the smoothest you have found the best location for the sub in your room. It may not be where you can actually put the sub though so you may need to compromise, but you now know where it should go. If this position is not feasible, try the front room corners.
3) I would suggest a separate sub for the LFE and the other speakers. This is a controversial position. I have found that a single sub, handling all the channels (including the LFE) simply does not sound as good. I run three subs in my system. One for the LFE, one for the mains and one for the surrounds…I do route the center bass to the LFE sub. This gives me smooth articulate bass and allows me to have a more boom oriented sub (ported) on my LFE where it is needed and keep the boom out of my mains where it messes with my music. Your results may vary.
4) EQ that thing. Your room can make a great sub sound terrible. Certain frequencies can be boosted as much as 20db by your room! You can tame some of this with an EQ (equalizer). The room is still going to effect the bass but you can lessen the impact with a well-adjusted equalizer on the sub-woofer.
Balance…that is the key to natural sound. Too much treble and your head will hurt, too much low end and you may feel nauseous. Use an SPL (sound pressure level) meter to properly balance your speaker levels. Follow the instructions on the tone disc or use the internal tone generator in your electronics. Either way, it is critical that all your speakers (including the sub) run at the same SPL for you to realize a properly balanced sound-field.
TIPS: Rounding out the sound
The golden triangle…seating position.
There are many equations for this. I will tell you of the one I found gave me the best results. Measure the distance between the left and right main speakers. Place a piece of masking tape on the floor in the center of that measurement. Now measure out from that piece of tape the distance you measured between the speakers…that is where you should sit. If your seating position is fixed, do this in reverse to find the optimum speaker locations. You can get great results in other locations as well and this is not the ONLY way to do this, it is just a way that works for me.
Place your speakers on an arc centered on the seating position. Take a string and have a friend hold it to his forehead while he sits in your listening position. Extend the string to your left speaker front. Now walk across the front of the room with the string and you will find where the other speakers should be placed. Often, it is not possible to place a speaker in its optimum place, then we must use the time delay settings on our equipment to compensate for speakers that are closer to us or farther away. What you will find though is that if you start at the center speaker sitting atop the TV with the string, that the left and right speakers will indeed be in front of the display. This is great ammunition to use with the spouse that insists that the speakers be flush with the TV.
Place tweeters at ear height. If this is not an option be sure to get it as close as possible or angle the speaker toward ear height at the listening position. The surrounds may be the exception to this rule. Check with the speaker manufacturer to discern the suggested position for the surround speakers.
You can aim your speakers by using a simple laser pointer available at K-Mart and other stores. Affix the laser to the top of your speaker using Blu-Tac. Make sure it is centered on your tweeter and parallel to the sides of the speaker cabinet. Sit a piece of cardboard in your listening position with a circle drawn on it so that the circle represents your head (height is important here). You could also use a friend but be sure he closes his eyes before turning the laser on. Now turn on the laser and point the light outside the circle on the side that the speaker is on (left of the circle for the right speaker etc). Repeat for the other speaker and know that the center speaker should hit the circle dead center. The three lasers should converge about 2’ behind your sitting position at ear height. This method works great for me.
Isolate your speakers. If they are on the floor, use some spikes or rubber feet. If they are on stands use some blu-tac between the speaker and the stand and between the stand and the floor. Rubber padding will help this as well. Isolating the speaker from what it sits on will do some wonders for the sound.
Wiring:
I will make this brief. I have found that wires (all wires, including power cords) will indeed make a difference in the sound of your system. Spend what you feel comfortable with and buy products with a liberal return policy in case you don’t realize any improvement.
Next, we will look at the video!
Mike
Mike Knapp
After being involved in this hobby for many years I have come up with quite a few tweaks that you can perform on your system to get the maximum performance from it. Many of them are just common sense and many of them are free or so cheap they may as well be.
Some of them will cost some money and you may need to decide if the benefits warrant the expenditure in your situation. So here goes….How to squeeze the best performance from your Home Theater System.
First lets look at the audio portion. In order to have a good surround sound field you must first have a good two-channel sound-field. If your two-channel front sound-field is flat sounding, so will be your film sound-field. Developing a good stereo sound is not an easy task, but the benefits of your labor will bear sweet fruit even in home theater use.
TIPS: Basic Speaker placement
1) Keep your speakers as far away from other surfaces as possible. Don’t place them right next to the wall or the TV or right beside a sofa. Let them have their space. The space behind the speaker is almost as important as the space in front of it. Keep your speakers off the back wall as much as you can get away with and make sure the fronts of the speakers are well in front of the display device. (disregard for FPTV’s with perf screens)
2) NEVER place your speakers inside an entertainment center cabinet. This is a common occurrence, especially with the center channel speaker. Avoid this at all costs. If you absolutely must do this be sure to treat the cavity in which the speaker rests with acoustic materials such as foam or fiber-fill.
3) If your center channel speaker sits atop your TV (very common) be sure it is angled down toward the seating position and make sure the front of the speaker is beyond the front of the TV as far as possible. To achieve the proper angle you might use a rubber wedge shaped doorstop and some blu-tac (sticky rubber sold at art supply stores) to make sure the speaker stays in place or there are some commercially available stands to aid you in this.
4) Make sure your speakers match. They should all be identical but that is often not possible. If you cant use the exact same speakers for your surround system, try getting them all from the same manufacturer with the same drivers in them.
5) Eliminate first order reflections as best you can. Sit in your listening position and have a friend walk down the side-walls of your room with a mirror against the wall at your eye level. When you can see your speaker, that is the place on the wall that needs to be treated to reduce first order reflections.
TIPS: Sub-woofers
1) There will be some contention in this area but what I will describe is what I have used and what has worked for me. First thing is to make sure the sub is the same db level as the other speakers. This will yield you the most accurate results. You may prefer more bass than this will afford you but try this first for a while before goosing the LFE. A well-balanced sound system will sound smoother and more natural.
2) Placement…this is a can of worms to say the least. What has worked for me is the “reverse engineering” method. Place the sub-woofer in your seating position (remove the chair/couch) and put on a thumping soundtrack of some kind or play a sub-woofer test tone loop. Walk around the room and place your head at about the same height it will be when you are listening to your system. When the bass sounds the smoothest you have found the best location for the sub in your room. It may not be where you can actually put the sub though so you may need to compromise, but you now know where it should go. If this position is not feasible, try the front room corners.
3) I would suggest a separate sub for the LFE and the other speakers. This is a controversial position. I have found that a single sub, handling all the channels (including the LFE) simply does not sound as good. I run three subs in my system. One for the LFE, one for the mains and one for the surrounds…I do route the center bass to the LFE sub. This gives me smooth articulate bass and allows me to have a more boom oriented sub (ported) on my LFE where it is needed and keep the boom out of my mains where it messes with my music. Your results may vary.
4) EQ that thing. Your room can make a great sub sound terrible. Certain frequencies can be boosted as much as 20db by your room! You can tame some of this with an EQ (equalizer). The room is still going to effect the bass but you can lessen the impact with a well-adjusted equalizer on the sub-woofer.
Balance…that is the key to natural sound. Too much treble and your head will hurt, too much low end and you may feel nauseous. Use an SPL (sound pressure level) meter to properly balance your speaker levels. Follow the instructions on the tone disc or use the internal tone generator in your electronics. Either way, it is critical that all your speakers (including the sub) run at the same SPL for you to realize a properly balanced sound-field.
TIPS: Rounding out the sound
The golden triangle…seating position.
There are many equations for this. I will tell you of the one I found gave me the best results. Measure the distance between the left and right main speakers. Place a piece of masking tape on the floor in the center of that measurement. Now measure out from that piece of tape the distance you measured between the speakers…that is where you should sit. If your seating position is fixed, do this in reverse to find the optimum speaker locations. You can get great results in other locations as well and this is not the ONLY way to do this, it is just a way that works for me.
Place your speakers on an arc centered on the seating position. Take a string and have a friend hold it to his forehead while he sits in your listening position. Extend the string to your left speaker front. Now walk across the front of the room with the string and you will find where the other speakers should be placed. Often, it is not possible to place a speaker in its optimum place, then we must use the time delay settings on our equipment to compensate for speakers that are closer to us or farther away. What you will find though is that if you start at the center speaker sitting atop the TV with the string, that the left and right speakers will indeed be in front of the display. This is great ammunition to use with the spouse that insists that the speakers be flush with the TV.
Place tweeters at ear height. If this is not an option be sure to get it as close as possible or angle the speaker toward ear height at the listening position. The surrounds may be the exception to this rule. Check with the speaker manufacturer to discern the suggested position for the surround speakers.
You can aim your speakers by using a simple laser pointer available at K-Mart and other stores. Affix the laser to the top of your speaker using Blu-Tac. Make sure it is centered on your tweeter and parallel to the sides of the speaker cabinet. Sit a piece of cardboard in your listening position with a circle drawn on it so that the circle represents your head (height is important here). You could also use a friend but be sure he closes his eyes before turning the laser on. Now turn on the laser and point the light outside the circle on the side that the speaker is on (left of the circle for the right speaker etc). Repeat for the other speaker and know that the center speaker should hit the circle dead center. The three lasers should converge about 2’ behind your sitting position at ear height. This method works great for me.
Isolate your speakers. If they are on the floor, use some spikes or rubber feet. If they are on stands use some blu-tac between the speaker and the stand and between the stand and the floor. Rubber padding will help this as well. Isolating the speaker from what it sits on will do some wonders for the sound.
Wiring:
I will make this brief. I have found that wires (all wires, including power cords) will indeed make a difference in the sound of your system. Spend what you feel comfortable with and buy products with a liberal return policy in case you don’t realize any improvement.
Next, we will look at the video!
Mike