A few questions for all of you: Why does Gene Roddenberry consider the animated series, plus parts of movies V and VI non-canon? I understand that his objection with V had to do with Spock's brother, but otherwise I do not know what material is non-canon or why. Did GR object to the aliens M'Ress and Arex on the cartoon? Are the Kzinti part of this problem? And what would he object to about Star Trek VI? If Rick Berman shares the "blame" for Voyager and Enterprise, it seems fair that he should share the credit for TNG and DS9 as well. What exactly was his contribution to these two shows? The supplements to one of the early TNG boxes mentions that GR, Berman, and Maurice Hurley would "arc" out each season, then assign scripts to individual writers. I know that the Executive Producer approves every aspect of production, every line of every script, etc. What was Berman's CREATIVE contribution, if any? Did he simply have more talent in the early years, and run out of ideas later on? Does his success depend upon the talents of the people he surrounds himself with? Would it be fair to say that his greatest contribution was hiring Michael Piller and Ron Moore in season 3? Did GR rewrite scripts on TNG as he did on the original series? Or did anyone else, for that matter? I understand Michael Piller would do an uncredited rewrite on later TNG scripts. How prevalent was this practice? And when did Roddenberry stop working on TNG? What happened between 1980 and 1986 to change Paramount's attitude towards Roddenberry? In 1980 the film series was taken away from him, but of course he was given the reins to a new series 6 years later. There must have been a regime change at Paramount in the intervening years. I belive Michael Eisner was in charge in 1980, and by 86 he would have been at Disney. Did the new Paramount regime have more respect for GR than the old one? What led to the introduction of the Romulans on TNG? I understand Roddenberry wanted to avoid Vulcans, Klingons, and Romulans in order to explore new species and new ideas. (Of course Bob Justman talked Gene into putting Worf on the show.) What led GR to reverse this decision re: the Romulans? I believe the Borg were intended to be the replacement for the failed Ferrengi. This last one enters into "rumor" territory. It was mentioned on another board that when Ron Moore joined the Voyager staff, Berman & Braga "forced" him out because the saw him as a threat to their position as top dogs. Does anyone know anything about this? I'd appreciate any input on the above from all you TV gurus and space cowboys.