POLL: Fight Club or Seven (Se7en)? (1 Viewer)

[John Randolph]

Which do you like better: Fight Club or Seven (Se7en)? I'm going to re-watch both back-to-back right now and I'll post the answer then.

 

[Bill J]

Se7en

 

[Richard Kim]

I think that Se7en is a superior film to Fight Club.

 

[Jim_K]

Se7en - easily

Fight Club is way overrated especially here on HTF - IMO. I'll admit its very stylish but that silly twist ending had me in stitches.

 

[MartinTeller]

Fight Club IS overrated, but I'd still say it's slightly better than Se7en.

 

[Bjorn Olav Nyberg]

Fight club

 

[JessV]

Fight Club

 

[Brian Lawrence]

Fight Club
I thought it was more inventive and had greater imagination than Se7en. Seven is the film that I would call over-rated, I don't think that it was a bad film at all, but it was really nothing more than a good serial killer story, with moody rain-swept cinematography and somber pacing. I give it credit for not trying to be a thrill a minute roller-coaster ride but when the film was over I found there to be nothing much to really think about. I still give it a thumbs up and have it in my collection .
Fight Club would not even make it into my top 50 of the 90's, yet the film was kind of wild , off the wall and a breath of fresh air coming from a director who looked to me like he was on the tired path of becoming another all style and no substance Ridley Scott.

 

[Rich Romero]

Fight Club BARELY. It usually all depends on what I'm in the mood to watch but I love both films.

 

[Ryan Satriani]

Fight Club...more original.

 

[Tiffany A]

IMO Se7en is far better than Fight Club. However, Fight Club is so unique that you should arrange to see it, as well.
(Don't eat spagetti before you watch Se7en)

 

[Scott Weinberg]

Tough call for me.
I think Fight Club may be the better film overall.
Ask me again tomorrow and my answer may be different...

 

[Rob Lutter]

Fight Club. It is one of the films that I consider "perfect" (definately in my top 10 of all time).

 

[Jefe Noche]

Se7en (by miles, and I like, and own Fight Club)
For me, personally, Se7en was a "sledgehammer that got my attention" the first time I saw it. The film, IMO, is a flat out masterpiece. One of the many amazing aspects of the film is that John Doe (probably the most twisted of any villians in any film) has a valid arguement.
Freeman's, Pitt's, and Spacey's performances are all dead on.
It has the coolest opening title sequence of all time.
And the "bad guy" actually wins.
What more could you want from a film?

 

[Justin Doring]

Se7en by miles and miles!

 

[Iain Jackson]

Fight Club

 

[Andy Olivera]

Se7en, though Fight Club is still an incredible film. I think both would make my top ten of the 90s...

 

[Michael Caicedo]

Se7en - No contest

 

[Steve Christou]

Se7en

 

[AllanN]

Fight Club - only by inches. Both where wonderfully movies, but I made a more personal connection with Fight Club.