- Joined
- Jun 10, 2003
- Messages
- 26,385
- Real Name
- Josh Steinberg
The Criterion BD is pretty perfect in my eyes - I have no complaints.
Just don't ask for a Pepsi FreeGoing back in time would be great!
Pepsi (& Coca-Cola) made in Mexico has real sugarAnd it’s Pepsi made with real sugar!
I couldn't agree more. It's a wonderful presentation IMO.The Criterion BD is pretty perfect in my eyes - I have no complaints.
I agree, Josh. It's obvious that whoever it is at Paramount signing off on their growing number of flawed releases doesn't know what in the heck they're doing. It really is unfortunate.With respect, I don’t think it’s as simple as “Paramount doesn’t want to spend the money to correct the disc.”
They released this 4K digital master in 2018 and the color has been incorrect and in public view for four years now. They have declined to correct it at any point over the past four years.
I don’t think this is a money issue.
I think this is an issue of, they believe they are correct. It doesn’t matter if they are not correct, or if we believe they are not correct, because they believe the version they have is correct. And since they believe it to be correct, they will not change it.
I think it’s as simple as that.
Mars has been known as "The Red Planet," and has been notable to us humans because of its reddish color, for a L-O-N-G time, and was described as such even in 1953. Heck, the very voiceover at the beginning of the movie intones, "Its rocks have absorbed almost all oxygen from its air, turning them red."To quote Bulldog from Frasier, This sticks!
The QC people must not be qualified or are given incorrect information.
Miss Kalas is doubling down again with the IB Technicolor print as reference. If only we can know this is what the film looked like in 1953. Perhaps Mars really was this blue and someone in the 1980’s made it red for home video releases?
Since they refused to fix what was wrong with The Godfather Parts I and II, we should have expected this response.With respect, I don’t think it’s as simple as “Paramount doesn’t want to spend the money to correct the disc.”
They released this 4K digital master in 2018 and the color has been incorrect and in public view for four years now. They have declined to correct it at any point over the past four years.
I don’t think this is a money issue.
I think this is an issue of, they believe they are correct. It doesn’t matter if they are not correct, or if we believe they are not correct, because they believe the version they have is correct. And since they believe it to be correct, they will not change it.
I think it’s as simple as that.
None of those photos existed in 1953, and in any case, only one of them is slightly bluish because it's enhanced to show atmospheric detail.Apparently the color of Mars can vary in photos depending on the angle, light source, and equipment. There are some pics of the planet that do appear almost more blue than red/orange:
View attachment 155198
So Criterion had their Summertime Paramount bascially doing the same -- we are right you are wrong. Wish someone had a original print that would set us all right!Since they refused to fix what was wrong with The Godfather Parts I and II, we should have expected this response.
Once again, thank god I have the Criterion.
or just understanding the audience in mind, this is a sci-fi movie not a science study....So Criterion had their Summertime Paramount bascially doing the same -- we are right you are wrong. Wish someone had a original print that would set us all right!
it could all be ended if someone had an original print out there from 53or just understanding the audience in mind, this is a sci-fi movie not a science study....