Wayne_j
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Nov 7, 2006
- Messages
- 4,901
- Real Name
- Wayne
I will probably just get the TMP director's cut and VI. I have the I - IV box set and I don't need to see V again.
I will probably just get the TMP director's cut and VI. I have the I - IV box set and I don't need to see V again.
I've never seen Trek V and from all the really bad stuff I've heard about it for years, I'm really looking forward to it.I will probably just get the TMP director's cut and VI. I have the I - IV box set and I don't need to see V again.
I've never seen Trek V and from all the really bad stuff I've heard about it for years, I'm really looking forward to it.
I haven't disliked any of the first four Trek movies so I am holding out hope that I'll dig V and VI. Presumably, TMP: DE can't be that different so I'll still enjoy that one.I actually really like it and suspect you’ll easily find stuff to enjoy in it.
Presumably, TMP: DE can't be that different so I'll still enjoy that one.
I had the VHS then the collector’s edition DVD and don’t remember the differences so they must have been subtle enough for me not to catch them.There are at least three different cuts of the film - the original theatrical version, the “home video version” that appeared on VHS and Laserdisc, and the “special collector’s edition” that appeared on the DVD. The VHS and DVD versions are very similar. I personally prefer the added scenes on the VHS version without the flash frames added to the interrogation scene on the DVD - Meyer in his commentary said he added them for clarity but I don’t think it was necessary, and it breaks the momentum of that scene’s brutal mind meld.
It won’t be the cut you saw on VHS if it’s the Director’s Cut that was on the DVD release in 2004.
The laserdisc of the film didn’t have those flash scenes during the mind meld, and the DVD has them, at least in the 2 disc collector’s edition. I see those flashes as helpful to the viewer that may have forgotten who is who. I can take or leave them.Eww… I supposed I had been watching a dvd of the regular home version because I definitely don’t remember the flash frames added to the mind meld scene. That absolutely kills the suspense of the scene.
BONG!!!Eww… I supposed I had been watching a dvd of the regular home version because I definitely don’t remember the flash frames added to the mind meld scene. That absolutely kills the suspense of the scene.
I’ll still watch 5. It’s not one I watch often though.
I went in another direction. Bought the streaming versions of all 10 films on iTunes for $35. The first four have since upgraded to 4K, and the remaining 6 should do the same as they become available. I will then just pick up the streaming version of The Motion Picture Director's Cut when it's on sale. No worrying about how Paramount will bundle them, and I really don't need these on physical media anyway.I waited on buying that initial 4-pack sort of figuring this would happen.
As much as I prefer the Director's Cut of ST: TMP, the question I have is, will the theatrical cut be included, or do you need to get the 4-pack for that edition? It sort of seems, according to the artwork, it's one or the other.
I went in another direction. Bought the streaming versions of all 10 films on iTunes for $35. The first four have since upgraded to 4K, and the remaining 6 should do the same as they become available. I will then just pick up the streaming version of The Motion Picture Director's Cut when it's on sale. No worrying about how Paramount will bundle them, and I really don't need these on physical media anyway.
Wonder if they're sticking with 2.00:1 for the VI Director's Cut?
I definitely had the 1999 DVD version, although I could have sworn that it was an anamorphic re-release. That was a number of years ago, though, so I suppose it wasn't.The first home video cut was the one that was on the DVD release in 1999. I remember that was non-anamorphic and pretty much a laserdisc port. No extras either.
Was it ever actually confirmed Generations was the third film to be included? I know that was the speculation, but I never bought it since Generations is a TNG film no matter how much you squint, tilt your head and want to believe it's not.I’m a little annoyed because I remember hearing that the next “set” would be V, VI and Generations. I was game to have two box sets that went up to the 7th film (I’m in the minority who really liked that one), but now they’re releasing a I-VI box set, or I can buy V and VI individually. Ugh! I’m gonna have to think upon this.