What's new

Panasonic RP56 opinions please (1 Viewer)

Kevin. W

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 27, 1999
Messages
1,534
I was out and about looking at DVD players to replace my Pioneer 525. I was looking at the Toshiba SD3750($200US/$320CDN), Panasonic RP56($180US/$295CDN) and also on of the JVC in the same price range. What one would people suggest. I'm really interested in the Panasonic.

Kevin
 

Pamela

Supporting Actor
Joined
Mar 14, 2001
Messages
779
I've had my RP-56 for over a month now, and I'm really happy with it. The first DVD I tested was Moulin Rouge, and the progressive scan picture quality was stunning. Everything I've thrown at it so far looks great. There is talk about it being flimsy, and it is. But that hasn't detracted from it's performance.

It's miles better than the Sony 560D i banished to the bedroom.
 

Kwang Suh

Supporting Actor
Joined
Sep 4, 1999
Messages
849
RP56 = flicker bug. Also, it's been discontinued. If you can wait, the RP62 is coming out Real Soon Now.
 

rodney wiley

Second Unit
Joined
Nov 23, 2001
Messages
307
I just bought the RP56 and I love it!! Got an awesome deal 129.99 so if it goes bad chuck it and get another one, But honestly its an very good player so far. I am anxious to see the new units and maybe upgrade?:D
 

StanT

Auditioning
Joined
Feb 8, 2002
Messages
8
I've had one for 4-5 months now with no complaints whatsoever. Mine sees only 2-3 movies a week, but has never skipped a beat, even on material that sent my other admittedly cheap GE player into convulsions. I know some have reported having problems with the player, but that seems to apply to the majority of DVD players. Only time will tell.
 

Steve Winkler

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Jan 13, 2000
Messages
179
Hey Kevin. I've tried all three of the players you mention. The Toshiba was a nice unit, barely noticed the chroma bug issue, put out a nice picture and has a number of nice features & settings i.e. screen captures, multiple video control settings, zoom. I did have a few problems with it dropping audio on some dts tracks though, and that was enough of a quirk for me to return it.

The JVC had lots of nice features, great price, but I found the picture it produced on my Toshiba 56X81 was way too soft and lacked detail. Thus it went back.

The Panasonic is relatively featureless in my opinion. The picture was as good as the Toshiba or better and I've had no video or audio glitches of any kind with this player. My thrust in getting a progressive scan player was picture quality above all else and I feel this unit delivers. Had the Toshiba not done the dts drops I may have kept that one, many more features + a nice picture.

By the way $295CAN seems like a good price for the rp-56. It's replacement, the rp-62, is in the latest A&B Sound flyer here in Calgary for $344CAN.

If you've got a store like Future Shop around, try them all. Return the ones you don't like.

Good luck,

Steve
 

elMalloc

Supporting Actor
Joined
Dec 26, 2001
Messages
787
Real Name
Reuben
rp56 has flicker bug but nothing as bad as the CHROMA bug most other dvd players have.
-ELmO:star:
 

BobJ

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
178
I see the flicker bug on occasion, but it doesn't really bother me because I like the CCS being on for watching animation. I'm willing to accept the trade-off. The 56 doesn't have the chroma bug--which is much more of problem to me than the flicker bug.

The 62 will be out in two weeks and then we'll know more.
 

Kwang Suh

Supporting Actor
Joined
Sep 4, 1999
Messages
849
The CCS being on has nothing to with the flicker bug. What the problem stems from is that CCS is configured incorrectly.

The chroma bug on some players is pretty damn hard to see. I have a hell of a time seeing it on my SD3750. The pulsating from the CCS misconfiguration is very obvious to me though.
 

Kevin. W

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 27, 1999
Messages
1,534
Well after all my research I picked up the RP56. I was able to get it for $295CDN($100 cheaper than most of the dealers in town have it for). I really think no matter which DVD player we get in the $200-300CDN range, problems will exist. So far I have watched only one movie(Oceans 11). I plan on calibrating my TV again with the new player before I give out my honest opinion. Though so far this player has been a big step over my trusty old Pioneer 525. Could some one point me in the direction of the flicker bug explanation. Thanks

Kevin
 

BobJ

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
178
The CCS being on has nothing to with the flicker bug. What the problem stems from is that CCS is configured incorrectly.
Hence the flicker bug.:) The CCS filter is the SOURCE of the flicker bug when it is set too high. Some high-end players have a switch to turn off CCS.
Link Removed
The Chroma bug drives me nuts, but I can live with the flicker bug because the CCS being on helps make poorly authored anime discs look better. I have a huge anime collection, so it's something that is important to me. Each person's needs and tastes are different. That is why it's important to choose something that fits your own needs and setup.
 

Kevin. W

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 27, 1999
Messages
1,534
Any actual pieces of software that show this? I read somewhere about the flicker in Shrek when he looks up at the ceiling while hanging on the chain in the Dragons castle. I couldn't see it on my TV(32" JVC). Also how do you figure out the firmware revision of this player?

Keivn
 

BobJ

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
178
Also how do you figure out the firmware revision of this player?
Without a disc in player press and hold on the front of the player the "stop", "pause" and "eject" buttons at the same time. Then press "7" on the remote and the info will appear in the display.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

Threads
348,419
Messages
4,844,950
Members
142,313
Latest member
andrebourbeau
Recent bookmarks
0
Top