Edwin Pereyra
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Oct 26, 1998
- Messages
- 3,500
Seeing that there is already a discussion thread started, here's a contribution to the review thread:
The Recruit from director Roger Donaldson (Thirteen Days, No Way Out) is to be enjoyed only up to the point when one figures out the story’s final trick but certainly no more past its 115-minute running time. The film gives out too many clues early on, which unfortunately, foreshadows the final resolution of its spy games.
It is layered with twists on top of twists. Those who are able to interpret the clues early on will find the film ultimately predictable and rather disappointing. On the other hand, those who don’t will generally find it enjoyable and even a good spy-thriller. Those who belong in the latter camp however, would be wise not to analyze the film as they exit out of the theater because in retrospect, certain scenes only work within the framework of a very tricky story whose only purpose is to confuse the audience – an aspect of the film that doesn’t necessarily work in its favor.
The film tells the story of veteran CIA agent Walter Burke (Al Pacino), who recruits a talented new prospect James Clayton (Colin Farrell) into the agency. Bridget Moynahan also plays another CIA trainee. All three principals give respectable performances in their respective roles.
The film is shot mostly during the winter months including certain scenes containing landmarks within the Washington, D.C. area providing its realistic look and atmosphere.
The film’s mantra is “Nothing is what it seems”, which is pounded into the audience’s head early on in more ways than one. By doing so, we keep our guards up expecting the unexpected and trying to figure out the film’s next move. I just wish the screenplay did not put too much emphasis on this thereby making it too obvious what the film was trying to achieve.
In a season filled with films vying for Oscar consideration, The Recruit provides some form of mild entertainment as a break from the more serious and cerebral fare. Even with its shortcomings, it is not a bad film and still gets a mild recommendation.
~Edwin
The Recruit from director Roger Donaldson (Thirteen Days, No Way Out) is to be enjoyed only up to the point when one figures out the story’s final trick but certainly no more past its 115-minute running time. The film gives out too many clues early on, which unfortunately, foreshadows the final resolution of its spy games.
It is layered with twists on top of twists. Those who are able to interpret the clues early on will find the film ultimately predictable and rather disappointing. On the other hand, those who don’t will generally find it enjoyable and even a good spy-thriller. Those who belong in the latter camp however, would be wise not to analyze the film as they exit out of the theater because in retrospect, certain scenes only work within the framework of a very tricky story whose only purpose is to confuse the audience – an aspect of the film that doesn’t necessarily work in its favor.
The film tells the story of veteran CIA agent Walter Burke (Al Pacino), who recruits a talented new prospect James Clayton (Colin Farrell) into the agency. Bridget Moynahan also plays another CIA trainee. All three principals give respectable performances in their respective roles.
The film is shot mostly during the winter months including certain scenes containing landmarks within the Washington, D.C. area providing its realistic look and atmosphere.
The film’s mantra is “Nothing is what it seems”, which is pounded into the audience’s head early on in more ways than one. By doing so, we keep our guards up expecting the unexpected and trying to figure out the film’s next move. I just wish the screenplay did not put too much emphasis on this thereby making it too obvious what the film was trying to achieve.
In a season filled with films vying for Oscar consideration, The Recruit provides some form of mild entertainment as a break from the more serious and cerebral fare. Even with its shortcomings, it is not a bad film and still gets a mild recommendation.
~Edwin