Paul_Stachniak
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2003
- Messages
- 1,303
Firstly who made the Clones? I know it was some mysterious Jedi who deleted the location of Kameno and all that. But who was he??? Did he would for Sideous? Why did the clones switch sides so easily? Where they programmed to obey Sideous? Was Sideous the one who order them?
Why does Artoo fly in the last two films and never again in the sequels? His mind wasn’t wiped clean, nor was any instruction made to rebuild him.
Why do the two suns of Tatooen only cast one shadow?
Why does it take 20 years to build one death star, and only 3 to build the other?
This film was a terrible end to a terrible prequel series. Forever I will see Vadar as a stupid, mindless kid who is fooled into the darkside. All the evil and hate he had in episodes 4-6 is gone. He's a pawn! A stupid mindless cyborg who had a bad dream and killed everyone cause of it.
Chewbacca will never again be seen as a space pirate. I don't know what kid in the future will ever believe he would rip out a man's arm sockets after being Yoda’s savior not to mention a war hero against the Empire. What gives?
What was the deal with Grevious? Honestly, who was he? How did he come to power? Why was he coughing? I’m assuming cause he was only a face and a heart in some metal body – but honestly why even bother setting up a character quirk like that and never follow it up. He was an action figure – nothing else. He served no purpose!
Why a powerful and intelligent Jedi like Yoda gives up so easily and decides to go into exile because he got his ass kicked is beyond what I understood to be the Jedi code. You'd think rather then admit defeat he would help set up the Rebellion. Not let his emotions cloud his judgment. But no - he falls down, cries, calls himself a loser and hides in a swamp. Why anyone would look for his advice on Jedi training I'll never understand.
Where did all the trade federation robots go in episodes 4-6? Anikin never had time to shut em down. They aren't walking around Mos Eisley in Episode 4?!
Do I need to go on?
What a joke these prequels where. They ruined so many of the character I grew up loving as a kid. It only left more questions to be asked. Lucas can give up this lie that he had these planned all along because I'm not buying it.
My fault for getting my hopes up again. Also what a boring film - if I had known Ankin's rise to evil would be so long, boring and drawn out I would have stayed home. Probably would have had more respect for him in the future.
Why does Artoo fly in the last two films and never again in the sequels? His mind wasn’t wiped clean, nor was any instruction made to rebuild him.
Why do the two suns of Tatooen only cast one shadow?
Why does it take 20 years to build one death star, and only 3 to build the other?
This film was a terrible end to a terrible prequel series. Forever I will see Vadar as a stupid, mindless kid who is fooled into the darkside. All the evil and hate he had in episodes 4-6 is gone. He's a pawn! A stupid mindless cyborg who had a bad dream and killed everyone cause of it.
Chewbacca will never again be seen as a space pirate. I don't know what kid in the future will ever believe he would rip out a man's arm sockets after being Yoda’s savior not to mention a war hero against the Empire. What gives?
What was the deal with Grevious? Honestly, who was he? How did he come to power? Why was he coughing? I’m assuming cause he was only a face and a heart in some metal body – but honestly why even bother setting up a character quirk like that and never follow it up. He was an action figure – nothing else. He served no purpose!
Why a powerful and intelligent Jedi like Yoda gives up so easily and decides to go into exile because he got his ass kicked is beyond what I understood to be the Jedi code. You'd think rather then admit defeat he would help set up the Rebellion. Not let his emotions cloud his judgment. But no - he falls down, cries, calls himself a loser and hides in a swamp. Why anyone would look for his advice on Jedi training I'll never understand.
Where did all the trade federation robots go in episodes 4-6? Anikin never had time to shut em down. They aren't walking around Mos Eisley in Episode 4?!
Do I need to go on?
What a joke these prequels where. They ruined so many of the character I grew up loving as a kid. It only left more questions to be asked. Lucas can give up this lie that he had these planned all along because I'm not buying it.
My fault for getting my hopes up again. Also what a boring film - if I had known Ankin's rise to evil would be so long, boring and drawn out I would have stayed home. Probably would have had more respect for him in the future.