Chris
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jul 4, 1997
- Messages
- 6,788
On the same day that I had the misfortunate of watching Alexander, I stayed for the second feature, "A Very Long Engagement."
I've spent the last few days thinking about what I wanted to say in this review, and how to present my general feeling about the film.
This is a story set around WWI. With most modern filmmaking, wars like Korea and WWI have largely been forsaken in favor of dramatic turns depicting WWII or Vietnam. But "A Very Long Engagement" cannot easily be defined as a "war film".
The film seemed to present ideas, feelings, thoughts far more then direct narrative. It's a slow building film that packs a monumental emotional "wallup" to it. In many cases, this can be seen as a psychologically anti-war film, delving into the psyche of the men who fight - and the lengths they will go to so that they will fight no more.
The film is well done, and presents the happenings in a very broad brush, with secondary characters who may not directly advance the narrative, but provide for a much more realistic feel and setting to the film.
At some point, the underlying messages can become too harsh, but the film does best with both subtle messages and prose.
The film plays as a poem put to film, and does a very good job at accomplishing it's task.
The cinematography is stunning in it's understated nature and stark changes.
Ok, I talked to a few friends about this, and wanted to delve into the middle of the film in a much longer take. Any film dealing with WWI has a very difficult time explaining it's matter. WWI is not as easy to explain to the common person as is WWII, or even Vietnam. In so many ways, even for those of us who studied history for degrees, it's difficult to encapsulate the emotions and feelings of the time and make sense of it today. The causes and effects behind the prolonged happenings of WWI seem almost.. antiquated and removed from us now. What helps this film is that instead of trying to bring the audience in, trying to inspire us to understand it, it ratchets it up and makes it "as it was" rather then tell us a narrative of the war; the reasoning is hard for us to fathom, and through set devices, it seems more distant in the past then it is - even at the time of her quest.
I have a feeling a great number of people will "read into" this film a number of different messages. And I have no doubt that the artist may have intended many of them. That having been said, I think more as a commentary about the human condition, the film succeeds.
:star: :star: :star: .5 /:star: :star: :star: :star:
I've spent the last few days thinking about what I wanted to say in this review, and how to present my general feeling about the film.
This is a story set around WWI. With most modern filmmaking, wars like Korea and WWI have largely been forsaken in favor of dramatic turns depicting WWII or Vietnam. But "A Very Long Engagement" cannot easily be defined as a "war film".
The film seemed to present ideas, feelings, thoughts far more then direct narrative. It's a slow building film that packs a monumental emotional "wallup" to it. In many cases, this can be seen as a psychologically anti-war film, delving into the psyche of the men who fight - and the lengths they will go to so that they will fight no more.
The film is well done, and presents the happenings in a very broad brush, with secondary characters who may not directly advance the narrative, but provide for a much more realistic feel and setting to the film.
At some point, the underlying messages can become too harsh, but the film does best with both subtle messages and prose.
The film plays as a poem put to film, and does a very good job at accomplishing it's task.
The cinematography is stunning in it's understated nature and stark changes.
Ok, I talked to a few friends about this, and wanted to delve into the middle of the film in a much longer take. Any film dealing with WWI has a very difficult time explaining it's matter. WWI is not as easy to explain to the common person as is WWII, or even Vietnam. In so many ways, even for those of us who studied history for degrees, it's difficult to encapsulate the emotions and feelings of the time and make sense of it today. The causes and effects behind the prolonged happenings of WWI seem almost.. antiquated and removed from us now. What helps this film is that instead of trying to bring the audience in, trying to inspire us to understand it, it ratchets it up and makes it "as it was" rather then tell us a narrative of the war; the reasoning is hard for us to fathom, and through set devices, it seems more distant in the past then it is - even at the time of her quest.
I have a feeling a great number of people will "read into" this film a number of different messages. And I have no doubt that the artist may have intended many of them. That having been said, I think more as a commentary about the human condition, the film succeeds.
:star: :star: :star: .5 /:star: :star: :star: :star: