Jason_V
Senior HTF Member
Okay, come on now...let's back up a second. We have a ton of hand wringing here over a character who appeared in one episode of a seven year series. Sure, it might be the easy way to create some emotion in Jean-Luc, but let's not give Rene (or Robert) more than they're due.
And yes, Jean-Luc should have taken more time to process their deaths. No argument. However, this all feeds into the Jean-Luc we knew for seven years. He says in Encounter at Farpoint that he's not a family man and is shown to not like children throughout the series-but he evolves somewhat over time. Family reunites him with his blood family and All Good Things... reminds him his command crew are his family, too.
At some point, though, the idea you won't have a "conventional" family hits you and you start thinking about the family name/family line. And then all of your hopes are pinned on one person (in this case, Rene). Family name and history is big for Jean-Luc, as we would see through the series. And when it hits you there is no one to continue the line, it's a gut punch. I watched Generations on Saturday night and came to the same realization; I will never have natural children and I only have a sister. The only people who can keep our family name going are two male cousins I haven't seen in easily a decade.
It does feed into the theme of Generations and the Nexus: going to a place where the missteps of your life can be fixed and replayed until you get the outcome you want. We saw that with Kirk and Antonia; we see that with Jean-Luc and Christmas. What else would be such a big pull for Jean-Luc that he might forget about Soran and the Enterprise? He has no massive "love that got away" (Vash and Janice Manheim don't count). He doesn't have a career regret (we covered that in Tapestry). So it's family and its history.
(psst...Geordi was also in a fire per Hero Worship a bit earlier than this fire, but that proves they do still happen.)
And yes, Jean-Luc should have taken more time to process their deaths. No argument. However, this all feeds into the Jean-Luc we knew for seven years. He says in Encounter at Farpoint that he's not a family man and is shown to not like children throughout the series-but he evolves somewhat over time. Family reunites him with his blood family and All Good Things... reminds him his command crew are his family, too.
At some point, though, the idea you won't have a "conventional" family hits you and you start thinking about the family name/family line. And then all of your hopes are pinned on one person (in this case, Rene). Family name and history is big for Jean-Luc, as we would see through the series. And when it hits you there is no one to continue the line, it's a gut punch. I watched Generations on Saturday night and came to the same realization; I will never have natural children and I only have a sister. The only people who can keep our family name going are two male cousins I haven't seen in easily a decade.
It does feed into the theme of Generations and the Nexus: going to a place where the missteps of your life can be fixed and replayed until you get the outcome you want. We saw that with Kirk and Antonia; we see that with Jean-Luc and Christmas. What else would be such a big pull for Jean-Luc that he might forget about Soran and the Enterprise? He has no massive "love that got away" (Vash and Janice Manheim don't count). He doesn't have a career regret (we covered that in Tapestry). So it's family and its history.
(psst...Geordi was also in a fire per Hero Worship a bit earlier than this fire, but that proves they do still happen.)