Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Speakers' started by CurtisSC, Jul 9, 2004.
Thats an interesting read. Considering Outlaw worked closely with HSU Research on the design of the LFM-1, the reviewer's observations don't seem too different than what Craig described in his review of the VTF-3MK II and the PB2+.
Not exactly the same designs used in either review, but not very far off either.
The Outlaw turns in a stellar performance.
It sure does. Actually both are given very high marks.
He didn't mention from what I could tell which one was more musical...
Having read the audioholics review, it is interesting. Both sound very similar on music, with the SVS going somewhat deeper, and the reviewer mentioning possibly the size of the cabinet having something to do with that...
Possibly ? That is pretty basic Physics...
For Scoring, he also said he used pricing as a weighting factor for each category. The tally, out of a possible 35, was the Outlaw got 32.5 and the SVS a 33.25...
Pricing... Outlaw ... $656 delivered, SVS $998 delivered...
Outcome of two Outlaws Vs. One PB2-ISD ? ... likely a draw... assuming co-location.
The Outlaw pair would be $1106 delivered.
Now... To the openly hostile Hsu Fans who accused me of bias, a hatchet job... etc... read both reviews (and Ed's too) ... I would love to get some comments.
Note - This is NOT a reflection of Hsu as a company. I love their products...
read both reviews (and Ed's too) ... I would love to get some comments.
Craig could I bother you to post a link to the review you speak of. It has been some time. If the link could direct me to the page where your assessment is boiled down that would be great also.
Steve - John Lepley did a link above... When you get onto the link, scroll down a bit, Low Roller posted the review as a summary ... And he did a great job, too.
Whoops!:b Forty five and going down hill fast you know.
Steve... You haven't even hit your peak yet...
Makes me feel better...I just turned forty.
Curtis - I am 44 going on 13... and no, YOU are not in the group I referred to above...
Remember... Life BEGINS at 40...
Thanks Craig......but then when is peak?
When I hit it, I will let you know...
Nice of you to say Craig but I know differently. More good clean bass and I ought to be good to go for quit some time?
In reading over the review once again my eyes couldn't help gravitate to the section dealing with dual 25-31PC+'s as apposed to the PB2+. You definitely thought the PB2+ performed better if I am not mistaken? Very interesting. I have been doing some contemplating lately on what next? PB2-ULTRA maybe? I wound up pulling my third 25-31CS+ from my system and putting it in the den. I don't feel like I'm missing out with colocated dual in my leaky 2880 cf HT and still have the headroom I feel is warranted. It just seems as though three 25-31CS+'s are a little harder to manage than dual and are a little more (precise)?? Very close though.
So I wonder if the conclusion I came to would be in sink with yours considering? I also know that throwing 300 watts apiece to the dual and 450 watts to the single in my case can skew things also but in either format the performance is incredible.
Sorry for the deviation Curtis and nice Thread/post
EDIT- You might be forty Curtis and a bit younger but imo your the more mature
No problem Steve. I do not mind OT stuff....I think it is all part of good discussion.
Edit- Thanks for the maturity comment. Some would argue with you though.
Steve... When I did the review, I had no idea that my 25-31 pc+ I owned at the time had original dB-12 drivers, and the PB2+ had the updated dB-12 drivers. Three subs, even co-located would be difficult... And two 25-31+ is really powerful. You seem happy with your system... I am not sure the Ultra will be a NEEDED change, but I will bet you would LOVE it...and then no worries about co-locating...
What it all boils down to in my case Craig, I think is that in all honesty. I just want to buy another sub. Maybe option one and option two is in order?
Anyway back to the review. All in all it was a fun read and done very well imo. Many of us can get quit leary of such reviews and try to read between the lines. It seemed (pretty) well done to me.
Steve... Option one being the PB2-Ultra ? I would say YES.. you will love that sub.
For the review. I thought the Audioholics review was extremely well done. They had more of a problem with the size of the SVS than We did here.
But the corresponding findings are remarkable... Between their findings and ours, in listening and measuring, the results we almost identical.
I have actually been in the same mode lately. I think I am holding out for a maple finshed VTF-3MK2. When I had the natural blond PB1+ here, it looked so good matched with the rest of the maple I had here. Plus, with my daughter practicing gymnastics in the livingroom, the downfiring driver will be better protected.