Need some help w/evaluation and comparison

Discussion in 'Archived Threads 2001-2004' started by Lew Crippen, Jul 10, 2002.

  1. Lew Crippen

    Lew Crippen Executive Producer

    May 19, 2002
    Likes Received:
    As I am a real novice in the whole HT area, and as there are a whole host of options available for equipment purchase since I last lived in the States (background: I’ve spent the last seven years in Asia/Pacific and most of the two years before that in South America) I have a general question on how some of you came to your equipment decisions.

    Basically, the WEB appears to give some very favorable options, insofar as value for money is concerned. I’ve followed several of the discussions for the last few months (I knew that I’d want to make some changes when I returned) and I see two general trends: (1) those who attempt to listen to their choices and make comparisons as to which speakers best fit their personal preferences and budget and (2) those who also include speakers which are not generally available for audition (and even when they are, do not lend themselves well for comparison purposes).

    I’ve read very persuasive arguments, from those of you who have purchased speakers sight (or sound) unseen and are quite pleased. I’ve also read the advice that as speakers is such a personal taste choice; you should listen before making up your mind.

    How is one to decide?

    To cite one example on my personal quandary, I am ready to replace my subwoofer (other speakers next). After reading several threads in this forum (and some other research), it appears as though SVS, Hsu and Adire all have models that would be satisfactory for my needs. I have, of course actually heard none of them. How is one to compare? And further, how do you make the comparison of any (or all) of these against similar models of brands that can easily be auditioned?

    And even within one manufacture’s line, how does one compare one model against another? For only one example, I’d like to listen to both the VTF-2 and VTF-3 and determine if the VTF-3 is, for me, worth the additional money.

    On the plus side, it appears as though it will be pretty hard to make an unsatisfactory choice, given the discussions in this forum. Still, I’d like to think that I made a reasonably optimal choice, though likely not the perfect one.

    I know that this has been fairly rambling, and it may not make a lot of sense to those of you who have been involved for some time. Still I will be quite interested in your thoughts as to how I should approach my choices, and as to how you made yours.

    BTW, although I don’t know very much about HT and how to choose equipment under today’s conditions, I am reasonably experienced over a number of years in listening to music on moderate to high-end equipment. My tastes are classical (especially opera), jazz, blues, bluegrass, C&W, etc. I plan to use the new system about 60%HT to 40% music, as I have a two-channel system from years ago that still fits my music needs.

    Thanks for any suggestions that you can provide.
  2. James Bergeron

    James Bergeron Supporting Actor

    Oct 9, 2001
    Likes Received:
    Flip a coin! [​IMG]
    I see your dillema, I guess you can demo them if you are willing to absorb the cost of shipping!
  3. BrianWoerndle

    BrianWoerndle Supporting Actor

    Feb 19, 2002
    Likes Received:
    I don't remember the site, hopefully someone else will, where you could search for someone in your area with an SVS sub that you could check out. Try some searching around and you might be able to find someone to let you check out their gear. You could check out my gear, but I am in St. Louis Missouri, so it would be a long drive for you.
  4. ThereseFontaine

    ThereseFontaine Auditioning

    Jul 10, 2002
    Likes Received:
    Hi Lew,
    I was in a similar dilemma over the past few months. (Although I never left the country!) We had an HK receiver with some decent Polk speakers, sub, dvd etc. When we built the new house we planned on doing the family room as a HT - finally got around to it a year later. I was extremely skeptical of buying speakers unheard, receiver, never mind spending thousands of $$$ over the internet or phone. I would be more than happy to share our journey with you, just send an email. As of Monday - the system is setup and done (except for tweaking). I ended up buying speakers unheard (Rockets) as well as the subs (dual VTF-3's). This was after spending numerous hours and weekends in various audio shops listening to what I had read might be "comparable" equipment. I auditioned many speakers and 4 receivers extensively - then found etailers who were extremely helpful and in the case of the speakers simply extraordinary - and decided that I could send them back if I didn't like them. To be clear I first ascertained what type of sound I was trying to achieve and then made comparisons predicated upon that. It is also helpful if you can bring some of the equipment home and try it out in your listening area, that made quite a difference from the showrooms as I knew exactly what all the settings etc were. There are some sites that you can list yourself on to find folks in your area that have some of the speakers/subs...Such as That might also be helpful.

    Good Luck

Share This Page