Mark-P
Senior HTF Member
I don't know if this means a disc is coming, but I'm in for $16.99 at iTunes!
My Fair Lady on iTunes
Watch trailers, read customer and critic reviews, and buy My Fair Lady for $16.99.
itunes.apple.com
The BD release has been criticized quite a bit.
I didn't' even know there was a corrected release. I have the 2015 BD release.I just want to be sure I have this right...
The initial BD release was a mess. However, there was a second corrected release a few years later.
Is that one being criticized as well?
I am all in on this 4k digital release, but it does beg the question as to whether a disc release isn't far behind.
2015 IS the re-do which was approved by RAH. The 2011 Blu-ray was the botched release that was done without RAH’s participation.I didn't' even know there was a corrected release. I have the 2015 BD release.
You know I'm not a big musical fan so you can see I haven't even watched my 2015 BD. This movie came out when I was a kid so I've resisted watching it from beginning to end. It was the same with The Sound of Music, but I finally did watch it as an adult and liked that movie very much so today. Anyhow, one day I need to rectify that My Fair Lady situation, but I'm more likely to do so if it's in 4K/Dolby Vision.2015 IS the re-do which was approved by RAH. The 2011 Blu-ray was the botched release that was done without RAH’s participation.
If you enjoy plays, you may have a greater pay-off of rediscovery and appreciation for “My Fair Lady”;as both musical and film; were you to first read George Bernard Shaw’s source work of “Pygmalion”. It all began there, and the challenge for Alan Jay Lerner was to create a lyric and language that would organically match the verse of its original author; who also won an Oscar in 1938 for his Best Adapted Screenplay of the same work. A tall order for Mr. Lerner; and one of seamless genius.You know I'm not a big musical fan so you can see I haven't even watched my 2015 BD. This movie came out when I was a kid so I've resisted watching it from beginning to end. It was the same with The Sound of Music, but I finally did watch it as an adult and liked that movie very much so today. Anyhow, one day I need to rectify that My Fair Lady situation, but I'm more likely to do so if it's in 4K/Dolby Vision.
Not with Robert A. Harris on watch.All for a solid 4K release... very preferably on disc, not just digital, but a tad skeptical of the Dolby Vision (or even HDR10) use/branding. Hope there's no weird, revisionist, funny business w/ the HDR processing...
_Man_
Not with Robert A. Harris on watch.
I wasn't aware that Mr. Harris had/has any involvement in the 4K release of MFL.
Oh he sure did! After the botched job on the initial BD release, Harris was brought on to fix it for the second.
I'm not talking about the 2015 Blu-ray release Ron. I'm talking about the upcoming 4K streaming service release.
Oh, apologies. I don't know if he was or not. I just figured a 4k scan was done so wouldn't they be using the same transfer?
HDR and Dolby Vision are not a part of the 4K scan that Mr. Harris was involved with.
Okay, maybe I misunderstand the process, but isn't that something that can be enhanced using the existing transfer?
AFAIK it's done during the mastering process using the digital scan data from the restoration that Mr. Harris worked on. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.