I'd buy both without blinking if I could count on Fox to incorporate the copious extras from the respective DVD releases (yes, I'm one of the lucky ones who's had the Behind-the-Seams edition of MRS. DOUBTFIRE since last year) but, since they never seem to, it'll likely be another pass for me...
Fox has been including most, if not all DVD extras on their BD releases since Fall '07 (save those titles that were originally scheduled for before that). It's MGM who has yet to port over extras.
HD Exclusive Content: Searchable Content Index -Dual-Menu Navigation System
Independence Day is listed as having the following:
Disc Features: • 2 Scene Specific Commentaries: Director Roland Emerich and Producer Dean Devlin / Oscar-Winning FX supervisors Volker Engel and Doug Smith • 4 Theatrical Trailers
HD Exclusive Content: • Interactive Game: "Alien Scavenger Hunt" (BD-Java) • Trivia Track • Search Content • Personal Scene Selections
Me, Myself and Irene had a commentary, deleted scenes, and the original trailer.
The Fly had all the bonus content from the DVD release. Mr. and Mrs. Smith had a fair amount of bonus content.
Yes, please do, because--with the exception of THE FLY--the titles you've listed offer only a fraction of the bonus features found on the SD counterparts and, as such, don't effectively ease my concern. If you're cool with truncated extras, more power to you--I know many share your mindset--but for me, when SD extras are left off the Blu-ray version, I'll be passing each and every time...
Well, I don't know how you can tell what "featurettes" on the I, Robot release are in full, but I digress. My point is that they are not barebones like they were a year ago.
In actuality, I rarely watch extras, and if I do it's usually once and done. I have 18 discs of Lord of the Rings and I think I've watched one documentary in 5+ years since I bought the first one!
Brandon, you and me have a simular mindset. I for one have been special featured to death. I could care less about those things anymore. I'll take 1080p and lossless audio over special features any day of the week.
The problem here is that there is absolutely no need for it to be an "either/or" proposition--a 50 GB Blu-ray can easily carry over all the special features from its SD counterpart, especially if they're not upgraded to 1080p (which would be nice, but if not, it's not a deal-breaker for me).
Exactly, I would never pass up on viewing a favorite movie in glorious HD because of a lack of extras which may only be viewed once, if ever. The movie will always be replayed.
All three titles will be released on May 13th, and come on BD-50s with AVC video and DTS-HD Master Audio soundtracks.
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
Historical and Geographic Trivia Track (BD Exclusive) Geographic Pop-up Map (track the location of Captain "Lucky" Jack Aubrey and his enemies) (BD Exclusive) Personal Scene Selections (BD Exclusive) Search Content (BD Exclusive) Master and Commander Theatrical Trailer (HD) (BD Exclusive) D-Box Compatible (BD Exclusive) Deleted Scenes: Weighing Anchor Shipboard Life Superstition Dentistry Articles of War
And hidefdigest.com just reported that BUTCH CASSIDY will contain most but not all of the SD's extras. Looks like I'll be passing on both this and MASTER AND COMMANDER...such a shame; I really want to give Fox my money. All they gotta do is follow Sony Pictures' model...
I too am in the "would rather get 1080p picture/lossless audio" camp but with all that extra space, it just reeks of a double-dip situation. The studios will just never tire of selling us the same stuff (only slightly modified) twice.
That being said, I'll probably spring for "Butch Cassidy."