Dave Scarpa
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Apr 8, 1999
- Messages
- 5,765
- Real Name
- David Scarpa
I guess I've Might have piqued your interest with the topic. So I'll Explain myself. When Paramount made the 1st Mission Impossible Movie I hated it. MI, like Trek was one of my favorite TV shows as a kid. So I went to the film adaption much like it was a trek Film. The Film Stunk for a variety of reasons. But mostly it was because of One Cardinal Sin by the Producers. They Made MR PHELPS the bad guy ! WHAT WERE THEY THINKING??? To take the main character and turn him bad. Whhat does all this have to Do what Enterprise? I ask the same question what are B&B thinking? What the hell are they doing to the Vulcans? I ask this question as I watch the latest ENT ep "The Andorian Incident". It was probably the best ep so far of the series but so what. At what cost?. First I won't even mention the obvious Plot holes like why did'nt Reed just beam the three of them out of there? Well of Course it was so later they could find the hidden Base. I'll go Deeper. What the heck are B&B doing to the characterizations of Vulcans in this show. They keep on having Archer say they are enlightened, but they come off as Racist Jerks. Even T'Pol can't stand the Humans "Stink" and she has to be reprimanded by the more toleran Phlox, what's going on here? Have B&B ever watched any single episode of the original series? Or any of the movies? I think it was a good Idea to have the human resent the vulcans, but the Vulcans themselves should be proving themselves as worthy Allies. Are these the same Vulcans we cheered at the end of First Contact offering a sign of Peace to the humans? Are these the same Vulcans we revered thru Spock and Sarek? Now I suppose it could be that future guy is a renegade Vulcan and the Base and these "Monks" are just their evil Minions, but I doubt they are that smart. And the Vulcans will come off as Highly Unethical and truely opposite of the character they have built from 35 years of Trek Adventures. I started to think I was watching Romulans. On one level I liked the Andorian Incident. And on another I hate and depise it.
------------------
My DVD Collection
The Megaplex
My Equipment List
------------------
My DVD Collection
The Megaplex
My Equipment List