John CW
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2000
- Messages
- 619
The Two Towers seems to have created a huge split in fans that Fellowship didn't. While almost everyone came to terms with the changes made to (the much more complicated) Fellowship of the Ring, people just can't seem to get over the alterations made to The Two Towers.
Are the book lovers taking things too seriously or is the feeling of a "souless" film right across the board? Or are the fans of the novel seeing something the rest of us have missed? Who knows!
Where do YOU fit in?
(I personally could easily have someone watch FotR: Extended Edition instead of reading the novel, but with TTT I think it's definitely a case of "the book is better than the film" -- Which I think is SUCH a shame! Does anyone else think that TTT had its heart and soul sucked out in the film version?)
Please pick one of the following four:
< 1 > - I HAVEN'T read the book and I LOVED The Two Towers.
< 2 > - I HAVE read the book and I LOVED The Two Towers.
< 3 > - I HAVE read the book and was DISAPPOINTED with The Two Towers.
< 4 > - I HAVEN'T read the book and was DISAPPOINTED with The Two Towers.
So, one, two, three or four.
Thanks!
Results (so far) are:
< 1 > - 6 votes
< 2 > - 20 votes
< 3 > - 2 vote
< 4 > - 3 vote
Thanks!
~ Johnny
Are the book lovers taking things too seriously or is the feeling of a "souless" film right across the board? Or are the fans of the novel seeing something the rest of us have missed? Who knows!
Where do YOU fit in?
(I personally could easily have someone watch FotR: Extended Edition instead of reading the novel, but with TTT I think it's definitely a case of "the book is better than the film" -- Which I think is SUCH a shame! Does anyone else think that TTT had its heart and soul sucked out in the film version?)
Please pick one of the following four:
< 1 > - I HAVEN'T read the book and I LOVED The Two Towers.
< 2 > - I HAVE read the book and I LOVED The Two Towers.
< 3 > - I HAVE read the book and was DISAPPOINTED with The Two Towers.
< 4 > - I HAVEN'T read the book and was DISAPPOINTED with The Two Towers.
So, one, two, three or four.
Thanks!
Results (so far) are:
< 1 > - 6 votes
< 2 > - 20 votes
< 3 > - 2 vote
< 4 > - 3 vote
Thanks!
~ Johnny