Ted Lee
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- May 8, 2001
- Messages
- 8,390
i understand that ultimately, whether i want to see a movie is up to me...but i do use reviews as a general guidelines to see how others interpret the movie and see how my views compare with the rest.
anyway...
after seeing rt give insomnia such a high fresh rating...something like 95% with over 100 reviews, i thought for sure that movie was just going to blow me away. i expected to be floored with such high rankings.
obviously i walked away less than impressed. it wasn't a bad movie...i just couldn't see how it got such good reviews.
(i'm no expert film critic, but i do consider myself an above average critic.)
so now i look at minority report - with 10 reviews it's already at 100% fresh. i can't help but think that's more than a coincidence. i'm willing to bet that by the time it's done, it will have a VERY high rating.
so, here's my question.
anyone can read a review and interpret it as positive or negative. i wonder who is sitting in the background of rt and making that call? who says whether that review they just read gets a fresh or rotten rating? i wonder if they're receiving any sort of "push" to put a positive spin on a movie.
anyway, i'm definitely going to see minority report so i'll be curious as to how i walk away, what my impression of the movie was and how it compares to rt.
anyway...
after seeing rt give insomnia such a high fresh rating...something like 95% with over 100 reviews, i thought for sure that movie was just going to blow me away. i expected to be floored with such high rankings.
obviously i walked away less than impressed. it wasn't a bad movie...i just couldn't see how it got such good reviews.
(i'm no expert film critic, but i do consider myself an above average critic.)
so now i look at minority report - with 10 reviews it's already at 100% fresh. i can't help but think that's more than a coincidence. i'm willing to bet that by the time it's done, it will have a VERY high rating.
so, here's my question.
anyone can read a review and interpret it as positive or negative. i wonder who is sitting in the background of rt and making that call? who says whether that review they just read gets a fresh or rotten rating? i wonder if they're receiving any sort of "push" to put a positive spin on a movie.
anyway, i'm definitely going to see minority report so i'll be curious as to how i walk away, what my impression of the movie was and how it compares to rt.