todd stone
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2000
- Messages
- 1,760
nt
Well check out the trailer and enjoy Obi-Wan telling Anakin to "watch out for (insert Lucas sci-fi jargon here)". Then they fly through them anyway and the results are some terribly corny shaking and babbling with electrocution straight out of Inspector Gadget or something. Just like a Jar-Jar moment.
Seth. I totally don't get your point. That's the kind of scene reminiscient of the original movies and their humor. That scene is absolutely nothing like Jar-Jar in any way. Some people will never be happy I guess. That said, I'm glad to have seen Jar Jar grow up.
The only positive thread I've seen is about the 6 year old watching Star Wars for the first time.
And even that thread has it's share of negative vibes, mostly relating to the Special Editions and The Phantom Menace.
It's sad that so many people are so negative about a series of movies that is so wonderful.
And before anyone says anything, I do not want to get into another useless Star Wars is good, Star Wars sucks discussion. I think we've had enough of those lately.
It's sad that so many people are so negative about a series of movies that is so wonderful.
Correction:
People say negative things about deleterious changes to a wonderful series of movies. BIG difference, Jeff, and one you find either impossible to comprehend or choose to blur over because you're uncomfortable dealing with the reality of what's happened to SW. It is utterly false to claim or imply that anyone who criticizes Lucas hates SW.
People say negative things about deleterious changes to a wonderful series of movies. BIG difference, Jeff, and one you find either impossible to comprehend or choose to blur over because you're uncomfortable dealing with the reality of what's happened to SW
You state this as if this was absolute fact, when it is nothing more than just your opinion. There are many of us who genuinely enjoyed TPM. I object to your insinuation that fans of TPM are in a state of denial that's it's a "bad" movie.
And yes, I liked Jar-Jar and his antics. Being an awkward and clumsy person myself, I can readily identify with him. I believe that there is this mean spirited instinct in people to pick on those that are different or don't fit in, which can be seen in the overwhelming anti Jar-Jar sentiment today.
I agree that it's overwhelming (which should tell people something). I disagree that people's motives are what you claim they are.OPINION said:Quote: