- Joined
- Jun 20, 2004
- Messages
- 3,527
- Real Name
- Richard W
Did you miss Billy Buck when you watched The Red Pony? Totten did some interesting work in the genre. He's best remembered for the mini-series The Sacketts, but I think The Red Pony might be his most memorable. What makes it interesting is that he eliminates the character of Billy Buck (played by Robert Mitchum in the 1949 version), the interloper who distracts the mother, competes with the father, and encourages the boy to break the rules with the red pony. By eliminating Billy Buck, the story becomes about an estranged family instead of jealously, rivalry and competition. The boy's affection for the pony makes more sense, too. A different set of emotional dynamics for the actors to play on. I didn't notice Billy Buck was missing at first because the story is well told without him. Perhaps Twilight Time will look into rights and think about releasing this version.PaulaJ said:Hey, Richard W, get outta my head!Twilight Time would be just the right company to rescue Robert Totten's remake of The Red Pony (Universal / NBC, 1973). This was a different take from the original, an entirely new adaptation, and I think a better one. A poignant coming of age drama in the west, involving a horse. It was shot like a theatrical feature and could have played theatrically. It equates with Hallmark specials like Sarah Plain and Tall and O Pioneers, only better. Played on a small intimate scale by Henry Fonda, Maureen O'Hara, and Ben Johnson. Clint Howard played the kid, when he was still young enough to be cute. The saloon fight between Fonda and Johnson remains the best fight I've seen in a western since Shane (1953). If I remember correctly, there was no music under it, just grunts and breathing and the sound of bone hitting flesh and boots scraping a dusty floor. They fight until they are too exhausted to continue. The film also offers one of the best performances of Fonda's career, and that's saying a lot. The score by Jerry Goldsmith will just slay you. The film was repeated a few times in the 1970s and I'm sure I watched it each time, but it has never been released to home video and is impossible to obtain in any shape or form. There isn't even a poster or stills to be had anywhere. The Red Pony needs to be rescued from obscurity.I watched The Red Pony just the other day, i.e., it is not impossible to obtain.
Definitely needs an official release. For the record -- the saloon fight isn't between Henry Fonda and Ben Johnson. It's mainly between Fonda and another character, the husband of a woman a drunken Johnson has just smooched. The husband punches Johnson down to the floor and while he sits there dazed, Fonda (almost as drunk) comes to the rescue. It's a great fight and seems very realistic to me, i.e., Fonda and the other guy are almost instantly utterly exhausted and spend as much time staggering around as they do delivering punches. Sheriff Rance Howard (Clint's dad) finally breaks it up. Ditto also on Noon Wine and The Westerner. Director Robert Totten had been a friend of Ben Johnson's since he (Totten) was a teenager and directed him in a number of projects, my favorite being a very touching episode of the 1966-67 series The Monroes called "War Arrow." Now there's a series that should also be released on DVD. (Teenage Barbara Hershey, anyone?) Someone told me that he had heard the reason it wasn't on DVD was that one of the actors in the show had some kind of ownership interest in it and had refused to sign off on a home video release. No idea if that's actually true, though.