Allan F
Agent
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2001
- Messages
- 44
I feel confident that I cannot be the only one who is somewhat enthralled by the plethora of speaker companies selling directly to the consumer these days. The concept of cutting out the middle man would logically result in more bang for the buck. Problem is, how do we know which ones really do sound better than others. It's not like we can audition them or even find a good comparison review (that I'm aware of).
My proposal: 1st: Someone needs to take the time to obtain lets say a good bookshelf from all of these companies at similar price ranges. (Axiom, Ascend, nOrh, HTD, ACI, Swans, etc.)
2nd: Get together a small group of reviewers and have each reviewer do an independant writup. Within the writup each reviewer would comment on the performance of each speaker and ultimately, rate them. Kindof a bookshelf speaker showdown of products available only on the internet.
Speaker reviews are obviously very subjective but I'd find this to be a very interesting study and at least it would give us some guidance. This is only my opinion. What do you guys think?
Allan
My proposal: 1st: Someone needs to take the time to obtain lets say a good bookshelf from all of these companies at similar price ranges. (Axiom, Ascend, nOrh, HTD, ACI, Swans, etc.)
2nd: Get together a small group of reviewers and have each reviewer do an independant writup. Within the writup each reviewer would comment on the performance of each speaker and ultimately, rate them. Kindof a bookshelf speaker showdown of products available only on the internet.
Speaker reviews are obviously very subjective but I'd find this to be a very interesting study and at least it would give us some guidance. This is only my opinion. What do you guys think?
Allan