Friends, As you know, I am a big fan of Super Audio but I also work professionally with high resolution PCM formats such as 88.2 khz. Well I had an interesting phone discussion today and some of the points we discussed may be of further interest and understanding to those of you looking at technical differences in the two formats. There is good news on both sides of the aisle and I wish to use the conversation to promote technical discussion and not yet another format flame war...so I will just keep to some interesting things he said. I spoke with a friend who works with a major DVD Audio creator. We discussed many things and he raised some interesting points. 1. He believes that transient response is better in DSD than in DVD Audio 24/96. In fact, he says it is clearly better in DSD. He thinks DVD Audio at 24/192 is a very different story and gives the edge to DVDA there in terms of transient response. Transients are the hyper fast attack-sustain-decay of notes that really add to a realistic presentation. 2. DVD Audio can only do 24/96 surround as the current capacity of the format does not have enough room for six channels of 24/192. He understands that HD-DVD is well underway at the DVD Audio group. HD-DVD will allow I believe around 23 GB on disc thereby allowing 24/192 for all six channels. 3. He feels it is really hard to hear watermarking on DVD Audio discs but not some of the encryption schemes on redbook where differences can be "apparent". 4. He believes that the major DVDA powers will not release any stereo only 24/96 titles for the time being as the DVDA group seems centered on surround sound as a primary driver. 5. He feels that redbook CDs days are numbered principally driven by the "ripping" phenomena going on out there. Wired magazine has done an interesting story this month on this. 6. He feels that DVD Audio will continue to improve as time goes on (and says same for DSD) and that the really critical factor for sonics is the original recording and the mastering thereof, more so than the high resolution aspect. In other words, a bad recording still stinks even with fast sampling rates. 7. He believes the next big DVDA title is a collection of 14 tracks from Emmy Lou Harris titled Producer's Cut, due on Feb. 25th. Recorded at 24/96. (This should be a great title) I just wanted to share this with the Forum and get your comments. I did not edit anything major from our conversation.