John Robert
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Sep 6, 2003
- Messages
- 193
Just got the December The Absolute Sound in the mail, and they had reviews of 2 players I am considering (and one I wasn't). Capsule summaries:
JVC XA-SA600BK ($300) - I had no awareness of this unit.
They say "On CD..., consistent sonic overachiever - approaching, in may respects, the sound quality you might expect from a $750 - $1000 player. However, it really came into its own with DVD-A discs...a screamin' good deal."
SONY SCD-C222ES ($449) - this one I have almost pulled the trigger on.
"The C222, though competent, didn't fully make the case for SACD...an overall flatness to the presentation ...a taste of SACD flavor, but it's more of an appetizer than an entree.
DENON DVD-2900 ($999) - Another unit I'm interested in.
"The DVD-2900 is lean and skeletal with all three formats. When I first fired the 2900 up, it was apparent that either the low end was anemic, or the midrange was just plain bright. As it turns out, I think both were true...While the video quality alone is worth $999, it's too bad the 2900 doesn't sound better."
Now I'm really confused! Any comments from owners of any of the 3 units? I was going to but myself one for Christmas...
JVC XA-SA600BK ($300) - I had no awareness of this unit.
They say "On CD..., consistent sonic overachiever - approaching, in may respects, the sound quality you might expect from a $750 - $1000 player. However, it really came into its own with DVD-A discs...a screamin' good deal."
SONY SCD-C222ES ($449) - this one I have almost pulled the trigger on.
"The C222, though competent, didn't fully make the case for SACD...an overall flatness to the presentation ...a taste of SACD flavor, but it's more of an appetizer than an entree.
DENON DVD-2900 ($999) - Another unit I'm interested in.
"The DVD-2900 is lean and skeletal with all three formats. When I first fired the 2900 up, it was apparent that either the low end was anemic, or the midrange was just plain bright. As it turns out, I think both were true...While the video quality alone is worth $999, it's too bad the 2900 doesn't sound better."
Now I'm really confused! Any comments from owners of any of the 3 units? I was going to but myself one for Christmas...