Oscar
Second Unit
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2002
- Messages
- 419
Brian´s idea for the end is excellent.
I like it.
I like it.
I loathe Sagan's lifelong dedication to scientific materialism
Well that's one way to put it, another would be to say that he was a humanist with faith/hope in scientific truth.
But that's a discussion for another thread, because I will not hijack this topic.
The idea of fading out at the moment of "Contact" sounds a bit too pretentious to me. The ending as it is now is kind of "Zemeckis" but then again Sagan read the script and OKed it so it seemed to him to be in the spirit of what his concept was, at least what I got from the novel was that science & religion need not be at odds with each other ( in the book they are VERY close indeed, albeit they don't realize it) and that believing in something (with intelligence, not fanaticism), be it religion, science or whatever, is better than believing in nothing at all.
A sequel to Contact would be as pointless as a sequel to Memento in my opinion.
I would love to see a sequel. It starts with a government employee finding the secret report with 18 hours of static. He releases it on Wikileaks. They discover why the recorder didn’t work and they fix that problem. They send a lot of other people who confirm that Ellie was telling the truth.
The proof of life on other planets starts people asking if religion is real. More and more start to think like Ellie.