Colin Jacobson
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2000
- Messages
- 13,328
Not if you're discussing the best DVDs. I run my own Top Ten list on my site, and I constantly try to balance good quality movie with high quality DVD. Extras play a big part in that. I've not picked a single-disc release for my year-end Top Ten since 2000; if a package is going to be considered among the best of the year, it needs a good roster of extras.
I'll gladly recommend great movies that're so-so DVDs. However, I'd never put them on a Top Ten. Actually, I started a little addendum on my monthly Top Tens last year so I could mention DVDs I highly recommend but that never made the Top Ten due to technical issues. For example, I'd push things like the "SCTV" sets - they're way too ugly to make the Top Ten, but I still highly recommend them.