DVD Review HTF REVIEW: The Buster Keaton Collection (RECOMMENDED).

Discussion in 'DVD' started by Herb Kane, Nov 30, 2004.

Tags:
  1. Herb Kane

    Herb Kane Screenwriter

    Joined:
    May 7, 2001
    Messages:
    1,342
    Likes Received:
    0
    [​IMG]

    The Buster Keaton Collection
    The Cameraman - Spite Marriage – Free and Easy





    Studio: Warner Brothers
    Year: 1928, 1929 & 1930
    Rated: Not Rated
    Film Length: The Cameraman: 76 minutes, Spite and Marriage: 76 minutes and Free And Easy: 93 minutes.
    Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1 Standard
    Audio: DD Mono & Stereo
    Color/B&W: B&W
    Languages: Silent/English
    Subtitles: French & Spanish (English included on Free and Easy)
    MSRP: $39.92
    Package: 3 panel Digipak in cardboard slipcover case





    The Feature:
    Similar to their release of last years The Lon Chaney Collection, WB is set to release The Buster Keaton Collection which includes another group of films from the “TCM Archives”. The films included are The Cameraman (1928), Spite Marriage (1929) and Free And Easy (1930). The first two films are silents, while the last film was Keaton’s first talkie film. Joseph Frank Keaton VI obtained his nickname when at six months he tumbled down a flight of stairs unharmed, he was then given the name "Buster" by family friend Harry Houdini. Buster was born in 1895 and died in 1966 of cancer.

    The first three films are also landmark in that they mark the debut of the star working for the lavish MGM Studio – said to be the “beginning of the end” for the great artist. After working as an independent for many years, in 1928 he signed with MGM and his fame dwindled and his life began to take a downward spiral. By 1932 he was divorced, a chronic alcoholic and in 1935 he even entered a mental hospital. Even though he was promised a greater salary, more publicity and the typical rewards of working for a large studio, the decision was not without its pitfalls either.

    As a result, Keaton would lose much of the control in the way of creative decisions. A decision that he himself, would later admit, to be the worst he ever made during his career. However, with the advent of talkie films, it seemed as though public interest in Keaton, the silent star, waned. Though his filmography seemed to be without many interruptions, his role with MGM was relegated to writing for the other up and coming stars of the studio while he performed only bit roles (with a few exceptions) including the highly regarded, A Funny Thing Happened On The Way To The Forum (1966) which turned out to be his final role. His entire career would see him only second in terms of world popularity to his friend and other silent legend, Charlie Chaplin.


    The Cameraman

    Infatuated with a pretty office worker, Keaton sets out to become a newsreel cameraman in order to be closer to his dream girl. Keaton’s first film for MGM, made in 1928, is considered one of his funniest masterworks and offers up a feast of visual gags. Unlike Keaton’s earlier works, the MGM studio now wanted him to strictly follow a script, allowing very little room for improvisation. In fact, one of the very few scenes where he was allowed to stray from a script takes place in Yankee Stadium while Keaton plays a baseball game with himself. The newly remastered DVD includes a new score by Arthur Barrow.


    Spite Marriage

    In this 1929 silent, laugh-filled classic, Keaton plays a fellow named Elmer, the proprietor of a dry-cleaning shop, who is hopelessly in love with a famous stage star, Trilby Drew (played by Dorothy Sebastian). Hoping to win her over, Elmer would dress up each night in a customer's tuxedo and attend her performances, under the guise of being wealthy. When Trilbey’s boyfriend gets engaged to another woman, she marries Elmer in a desperate attempt to get even. This was Keaton’s final silent comedy and is presented here with its original Vitaphone music score. Ironically enough, Keaton wanted to do this film with sound however, the MGM soundstages were booked to capacity and MGM wouldn’t permit it.


    Free and Easy

    In Keaton’s first talkie, he stars as an agent to beauty contest winner Elvira Plunkett (played by Anita Page). When Elvira decides to try her luck in Hollywood, Elmer goes along to help and the two soon find themselves falling in love. Chaos ensues when the couple must contend with Elvira’s disapproving mother and a handsome movie star, who also has his sights set on the lovely Elvira. Known for his sight gags, not his dialogue, MGM was about to move forward with the new technology that would indeed, signal the “beginning of the end” for Buster Keaton. This 1930 classic is highlighted by guest appearances from a host of other MGM stars of the era including Robert Montgomery and Lionel Barrymore.

    A little bit about the packaging. The set consists of two discs housed in a 3 panel Digipak, which slips nicely into a cardboard slipcover case. Each of the panels contains a list of the various chapter stops, great looking photographs and a picture of each of the original movie posters. The rear panel lists the entire cast & crew credits for each of the three productions. Also similar to last year’s Chaney set, the Keaton Collection is packaged handsomely which I’m sure will please all fans of the “Great Stone Face”. Very classy indeed.

    The Features:
    The Cameraman - [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]
    Spite Marriage - [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]
    Free and Easy - [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]



    Video:
    All of the films show remarkably well. Throughout the course of all three, there are various reels which are weaker than others, but by and large this set exceeds my expectations. Personally, I thought overall, Spite Marriage looks slightly better (on the whole) than The Cameraman and Free and Easy.

    All of the films display decent black levels with better than average whites. The level of contrast and shadow detail is excellent. As we might expect, there is a fair amount of film grain however, it is by no means excessive.

    Image definition is rather erratic and difficult to comment on as a whole. Some reels look terrific, while others look slightly soft and dupey. One would assume that a number of various sources were used resulting in the varying quality – not a criticism, but an observation. The same observation can be said for what most of us would be concerned with from film of this vintage – the condition, blemishes, dust, dirt, scratches etc. Again, there are a number of blemishes that show up from time to time and it would appear that Spite Marriage shows slightly cleaner with fewer blemishes to report.

    I don’t know if any sort of restoration was undertaken with these films, but these transfers do fall short of the previous Chaplin sets, despite the PAL debacle. They do look terrific however, and again consideration granted for films that are 75+ years old.

    Video: 4/5
    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]



    Audio:
    Okay, so you’re saying “how difficult can it be to evaluate audio on silent films”…? Well, in this case, pretty simple really - but I’ll mention a few things, mostly highpoints on this trouble free set. On disc one, The Cameraman and the “So Funny It Hurts: Buster Keaton and MGM” documentary on the second disc are in DD stereo. The Cameraman is accompanied by a new score by Arthur Barrow. The other two films (Spite Marriage & Free and Easy) are presented in mono.

    All of these tracks are cleaner than I anticipated – I don’t know why, but I assumed there would be slightly more hiss and background noise and what not – thankfully there isn’t.

    On the Free and Easy track, it too is clean and basically free of noisy distractions. As you might imagine, the dynamics are wafer thin and slightly edgy but all of the dialogue is easily discernable and quite clear actually. As for the accompanying music, except for the newer 2.0 score on The Cameraman, there isn’t much of soundstage per se as everything is anchored to the center channel.

    Audio: 4/5
    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]



    Special Features:
    This set is complemented by a number of supplements that are highly informative and entertaining. They are:

    Disc One:

    The Cameraman

    [*] An Introduction by Robert Osborne. Both intros are worthwhile as Mr. Osborne covers a lot of ground quickly offering up numerous tidbits relating to each film. Duration: 2:04 minutes.
    [*] A Commentary by Glenn Mitchell. Obviously the gentlemen who have appeared for this and the Spite Marriage commentary are veritable experts when it comes to Buster Keaton and his works. They offer up a treasure trove of interesting trivia and informative facts relating to Keaton and his films.
    [*] Photo Montage is also included where approximately 50 B&W still photos are shown in a slideshow like manner accompanied by piano music. Duration: 2:36 minutes.

    Spite Marriage
    [*] An Introduction by Robert Osborne. Duration: 2:36 minutes.
    [*] A Commentary by John Bengston and Jeffrey Vance. As I mentioned above, these commentaries are certainly worth your time as they are presented by experts of the films.
    [*] Photo Montage is also included which starts with a color photo of the movie poster and includes several dozen B&W still photos in a slideshow like manner accompanied by music. Duration: 2:16 minutes.


    Disc Two:

    Free And Easy


    On the second disc, there are no features specific to film itself, but included is a documentary entitled:
    [*] So Funny It Hurts: Buster Keaton and MGM. The feature is narrated by James Karen actor/friend of Keaton. The documentary does an exemplary job at chronicling Keaton’s displeasure with his time spent with MGM and shows several clips from an old interview where Buster speaks quite candidly about many of his personal experiences there. It’s also interesting to see several scene for scene comparisons of Red Skelton’s work compared to Buster’s from years earlier. Obviously a consummate professional, Keaton speaks of the lack of commitment from the younger generation that he worked with. The feature was produced for TCM by Kevin Brownlow and Christopher Bird specifically for this set in 2004. Although the documentary is terrific, I can’t help wishing it had been longer. Duration: 39:19 minutes.

    Special Features: 4/5
    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    **Special Features rated for the quality of supplements, not the quantity**



    Final Thoughts:
    The three films that have been included are historically important unfortunately marking the (sad) decline for the legendary actor/filmmaker. There’s no doubt that The Cameraman is the crown jewel in the set however, Spite Marriage is almost as worthy and Free and Easy also has its moments but falls just short of the brilliance of the previous two.

    Sadly, it’s no surprise that interest in classic film in general is waning, never mind silent classic film. WB’s decision to release another set of silent films, admittedly a somewhat obscure set, is further proof positive of the commitment to their loyal fans of classic movies.

    This is a terrific collection of Keaton films with presentations that have probably never been better. They are complemented with informative commentaries and an excellent documentary, as well as several other interesting little additions. And to top it all off, the packaging is elegant and classy. If you’re a fan of Keaton, dare I say, you are about to be very pleased.

    Overall Rating: 4/5 (not an average)
    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    Recommended.





    Release Date: December 7th, 2004
     
  2. John Hodson

    John Hodson Producer

    Joined:
    Apr 14, 2003
    Messages:
    4,533
    Likes Received:
    320
    Location:
    Bolton, Lancashire
    Real Name:
    John
    Nice review Herb; I would have expected the documentary to be a little longer too. Minor quibble - sounds like a great set.
     
  3. Eric Peterson

    Eric Peterson Cinematographer

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2001
    Messages:
    2,959
    Likes Received:
    1
    Great review!

    I can't wait to get my hands on this. It's taken me 3 years to completely cover my Kino boxset, and I'm now yearning for more Keaton.

    I hope that we get the feature length Brownlow documentary about Keaton on DVD soon.
     
  4. Mark Zimmer

    Mark Zimmer Producer

    Joined:
    Jun 30, 1997
    Messages:
    4,300
    Likes Received:
    40
    Very much looking forward to this set; these early MGM films are not readily available (though bad prints have shown up on TCM from time to time) and this pretty much completes the classic Keaton on DVD between the Kino set and the various Arbuckle collections from Image, Kino and Milestone.

    I suspect one reason the Brownlow documentary is so short is that he has already done one large-scale Keaton documentary that couldn't be used for this set for legal reasons and he didn't want to repeat himself.
     
  5. ArthurMy

    ArthurMy Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2004
    Messages:
    590
    Likes Received:
    0
    I got my set and pretty much can agree with Herb's assessment. Those who were complaining about The Coconuts and other Marx Brothers transfers will either ignore the blemishes on The Cameraman or they won't be so happy. But I'm happy because, for the most part, as Herb says, they look just fine for their age and again, who knows what elements survive, which is always the problem. Kevin Brownlow's documentary is wonderful (other people who do featurettes on DVDs should watch and learn from him). I'd never seen these films - for me, The Cameraman was a masterpiece, despite the Arthur Barrow score which just wasn't my cup of tea. Spite Marriage, while very funny, just didn't have the bravura that Keaton's best work has, and the talkie was a bit cumbersome, but still had its moments.
     
  6. Michael Elliott

    Michael Elliott Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Jul 11, 2003
    Messages:
    7,500
    Likes Received:
    229
    Location:
    KY
    Real Name:
    Michael Elliott
    Excellent review Herb. This is certainly my most wanted title of the year. I personally thought Warner's CHANEY COLLECTION was the best release of last year. I haven't seen any of these films, which is another plus.

    It's too bad about the earlier doc not being able to be included. I watched his documentary on Harold Lloyd and Cecil B. DeMille the past week and loved them. Hopefully the Keaton and Universal Horrors docs can be released soon.
     
  7. Patrick McCart

    Patrick McCart Lead Actor

    Joined:
    May 16, 2001
    Messages:
    7,549
    Likes Received:
    179
    Location:
    Georgia (the state)
    Real Name:
    Patrick McCart
    One thought on The Cameraman...

    For years, MGM held only a battered 16mm print. In the early 1990's, David Shepard (the pioneer of silent films on home video) was looking through a vault with various elements used by Robert Youngson. Well, among materials for MGM's Big Parade of Comedy was a pristine 35mm fine-grain positive of The Cameraman which was used in 1964 to create duplicate negative clips for use in the compilation film. Film Technology Inc. restored the film for Turner Entertainment. I dare anyone to not be amazed by the quality of the restoration compared to the 16mm element for the original MGM/UA VHS.


    I can't wait to see this DVD... I recorded the remastered version (although, before the new score was added, so it still had the horrible quality piano score), but the recording somehow screwed up, resulting in a fantastic transfer being covered up with a ton of tape noise. No wonder I decided to stop messing with VHS.

    Kevin Brownlow's excellent documentary, Buster Keaton: A Hard Act to Follow, really ought to be on DVD. With Warner's 2-disc Keaton set, 100% of Keaton's silent films are on DVD (except for one lost Arbuckle short). Not even Chaplin has this much material on DVD (the Keystones remain only on PD DVD's with a few popping up on the Slapstick Encyclopedia set). I'm hoping that whoever holds the rights to A Hard Act To Follow will eventually release it on DVD. HBO released the VHS tapes. I'm guessing either A&E or Image Entertainment would have DVD rights now.
     
  8. Steve...O

    Steve...O Producer

    Joined:
    Dec 31, 2003
    Messages:
    4,157
    Likes Received:
    680
    Real Name:
    Steve
    Thank you Herb for another informative review!

    I can't send enough praise to Warners for showing the respect towards not only their classic catalog but the consumer as well. It is one thing to release titles such as this, but to include meaningful supplemental content demonstrates the dedication that Mr. Feltenstein and his staff have towards putting out one quality product after another. I hope these sets do well for Warners so that we can continue to see the TCM Archives product line continue for quite some time.

    Steve
     
  9. George See

    George See Second Unit

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2002
    Messages:
    486
    Likes Received:
    0
    I don't currently own any Buster Keaton films on dvd, i've seen some of his movies in the past on tv but never really spent any money or time on him but i'm definitly interested. Would this set serve as a decent introduction to his work?
     
  10. Jaime_Weinman

    Jaime_Weinman Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Mar 19, 2001
    Messages:
    786
    Likes Received:
    17
    For a first Keaton DVD, I think I would suggest the disc of The General and Steamboat Bill Jr.. No extras, but the films themselves are from Keaton's best period. But I'm getting the WB set for The Cameraman and the (apparently) excellent extra material.
     
  11. Jack Theakston

    Jack Theakston Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Aug 3, 2003
    Messages:
    858
    Likes Received:
    66
    Location:
    New York
    Real Name:
    Jack Theakston
    I also highly suggest SEVEN CHANCES, which has the best foot chase ever captured on film.
     
  12. Thi Them

    Thi Them Producer

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 1999
    Messages:
    3,649
    Likes Received:
    0
    Can someone tell me the ending of The Cameraman? My recording from TCM got cutt off after the beach scene.

    Thanks.

    ~T
     
  13. Dick

    Dick Producer
    Supporter

    Joined:
    May 22, 1999
    Messages:
    5,804
    Likes Received:
    1,828
    Real Name:
    Rick
    Which Keaton film has a sequence of him being chased down a mountainside by a landslide of huge tumbling rocks? Hilarious.
     
  14. Patrick McCart

    Patrick McCart Lead Actor

    Joined:
    May 16, 2001
    Messages:
    7,549
    Likes Received:
    179
    Location:
    Georgia (the state)
    Real Name:
    Patrick McCart

    Seven Chances.
     

Share This Page