HTF REVIEW: "Mystery Science Theater 3000" Volume 2 (with screenshots)

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
55,912
Real Name
Ronald Epstein


Mystery Science Theater 3000
Volume Two






Studio: Rhino
Year: 1993
Rated: NR
Film Length: 380 minutes
Aspect Ratio: Full Frame (1.33:1)
Subtitles: None




I was sort of surprised when a week ago I opened
up one of the many screener packages I normally
receive and found a copy of Mystery Science
Theater 3000 Volume 2
inside. Since the set
had been released weeks before the screener was
sent, I really didn't care to write a review.
Those that had wanted the set already bought it
and knew exactly what was already inside.

A funny thing happened between the day I received
that set and today. With the insistence of MST3K
fans of this forum, I found myself sitting down
and sampling the material on this DVD collection.
It wasn't long before watching MST3K became
a nightly ritual as I watched chapter after chapter
of the assortment of short films that comprise
Shorts One. Man, this stuff is funny!

For those of you unfamiliar with Mystery Science
Theater 3000
, it was originally an idea
conceived by Joel Hodgson, a stand-up comedian, and
Jim Mallon, a production manager at a Minneapolis
UHF television station. The show debuted in 1988
and quickly became such an underground hit that
within a year it had moved to The Comedy Channel.
Over the next three years the show received five
cable Ace and two Emmy award nominations. In 1994,
the show won the prestigious Peabody Award.



So what's the hype all about? Imagine a series
where the hero (Mike Nelson) is a hapless guy who's
trapped on an orbiting satellite and forced by evil
scientists to watch horrible movies as part of a
diabolical experiment. He sits watching the movie
with a pair of the ship's robots (Tom Servo and Crow).
The only way they can keep sane is to make fun of
the movies. This is where the comedy ensues as the
three offer an offbeat combination of wisecracks and
brainy satire.

I admit that I really haven't been aware of these
boxed sets being released. I have only received
Volume 2 and already as I write this review,
I discover that Volume 3 is already shipping.
Since I am only vaguely familiar with this show
(I have watched it only a few times on The Comedy
Channel), I really can't comment on how well Rhino
has compiled the material here. I'm going to do
the best I can based on what is in front of me....



Mystery Science Theater 3000 arrives in
a rather deluxe 4-disc boxed set. The outer
slipcover cardboard packaging is somewhat sturdy
and I really dug the fact that it contained a
fun little picture wheel that enables you to turn
the cover artwork to your liking.



The innards unfold to a 4-pane gatefold that
hold the 4 discs in raised plastic hub housing.
The outer panes contain fun pictures of Joel
Hodgson, Mike Nelson, Crow and Tom Servo. The
back pane contains a full description of the
included movies/shorts, Angels Revenge, Cave
Dwellers, Pod People
and Shorts One.
A outer pane pocket contains an 8-page booklet
that breaks down these features by chapter number.
The only thing that seems to be missing here is
any indication of the show's original air date.

As I noted above, it wasn't my intent to do a
review of this boxed set, but I had such a great
watching Shorts One, that I felt I should
make an appearance here and talk about how much
fun I had watching this particular disc.



Shorts One is a collection of seven really
bad short films. These are the kind of bad,
low-budget wholesome films that many of you
probably remember from your earliest school days.
All sorts of subjects are tackled here from
personal grooming to making a date with your
family. I particularly enjoyed the gang making
fun of two young boys getting hog-tied into putting
on a rodeo for the locals, and a student council
President who is cited for cheating on his exam.
Once you begin watching just one of these shorts,
I promise you'll laugh so hard that you'll quickly
finish them all. This is some seriously good
entertainment here!


How is the transfer?

First, let me state that I am basing this
review based upon the 4th disc in this collection,
entitled Shorts One.

The shows are presented in their original full
screen ratio. The overall transfer seems to look
marvelous, but you could really only judge it by
the brief amount of exclusive material shot for
this Rhino video releases which features Tom
Servo as the 'host.' These segments look well
polished with vibrant colors and without a spec
of added video noise. Once the lights go down
and the features begin, we are at the mercy of
the often distressing quality of these cheesy
films. I can say that the show looks as good as
what I would expect from a cable TV broadcast.



The audio seems to be mostly mono here. Character
dialogue is very strong in the center channel, but
there is bleeding across the front mains. The only
segments that I could detect any expanded audio is
those featuring hosting narration by Tom Servo (with
the sound of the ships engines in the rears) and
the Main Menus (which feature the sound of a projector
running in the rears). These sequences are apparantly
recorded in Dolby Digital 2.0. The character dialogue
is distinctively crisp, separating itself nicely
from the main feature.

Special Features



The specs on the Press release mentioned the
inclusion of trailers for each of the film
presentations. I did a search on all 4 of
these discs and could not locate any trailers --
at least -- these did not seem to be indicated
on the chapter stops.

Rhino has also neglected to offer and subtitles
or closed-captioning for the hearing impaired.


Final Thoughts



I apologize to the fans of MST3K for being
very brief in my overview of this set. You fans
certainly deserved more. This wasn't, however, a
review I intended to do -- that is -- until I saw
the obnoxiously funny material on the Shorts One
disc. If this is any indication of what appears
on the rest of these discs, this DVD is an absolute
winner!


Release Date: NOW


All screen captures have been further compressed.
They are for illustrative purposes only and do not
represent actual picture quality
 

Adam Tyner

Screenwriter
Joined
Sep 29, 2000
Messages
1,410
Not to nitpick, but...


[*]It's "MST3K", not "MSTK3".[*]There's no "5.1 audio" anywhere that I can find. The feature itself is Dolby Digital 2.0 (192Kps), and the menus (at least on the Shorts disc) are LPCM 2.0 (1536Kps).[/list]
 

Jeff Kleist

Executive Producer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 4, 1999
Messages
11,267
Another quicky
You mention Mike as the host of the show underneath a picture of Joel Hodgeson
Mike was the second host.

The Tom Servo footage was shot by Best Brains for their original internal release of Shorts One, which was later released to retail by Rhino, and then to DVD by the same

I only wish the other internal releases will someday make it to DVD, like their documentary on doing the last episode, "Tom Servo's Favorite Host Segments" (v.1-4 of all the great stuff on features they can't get video rights for)

Never want to lose a chance to show off my girl


 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
55,912
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
Jeff,

Photos do not always match up with the text, as
you will see in many of my other reviews. I usually
place photos in the best available positions.

As for the 5.1 audio -- it is listed on the specs
sheet that retailers received. As noted in the review,
the audio separation contained a lot of bleeding. I
have updated the review to reflect the Dolby Digital
2.0.

Thanks
 

Walt Riarson

Supporting Actor
Joined
Jan 13, 2002
Messages
809
If this is any indication of what appears
on the rest of these discs, this DVD is an absolute
winner!
If you only watch one of the other films included, be sure to watch Cave Dwellers. Aside from being one of the absolute funniest episodes ever, it's also presented in the 'shoebox format'.
 

Bruce Hedtke

Effects Supervisor
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jul 11, 1999
Messages
2,249
If you liked the shorts, you'll like the full length episodes, probably more. Watch enough to start catching the self-referencing they do so well and that's where they are at the funniest.
Example in the current set (Collection 3): The Atomic Brain-girl is walking through a wooded yard in a white flowing gown and Crow says "I'm looking for the Manos set"


I liked the individual releases but the boxsets are definitely the way to go as far as future releases. Can't wait for the next!

Bruce
 

Sean_J

Agent
Joined
Feb 2, 2002
Messages
46
The episodes being released on DVD have UPSET ME. I believe there are better episodes that should be on dvd (ie SoulTaker, Space Mutiny, Squirm)... The episode choices for the DVDs are poor. Plus, I wish they would release season sets (although there are alot of episodes and there would probably be alot of dvds for JUST one season of MST).
 

Adam Tyner

Screenwriter
Joined
Sep 29, 2000
Messages
1,410
Season boxes will never happen. Way too many rights issues to overcome.

The episodes being released on DVD by Rhino are those that have already been released on VHS. The three episodes you named are all Sci-Fi-era episodes, and Rhino has yet to release an episode from season 8 and on on home video. Any future box set, assuming one is forthcoming, will presumably include previously unreleased material.

I disagree that the episode choices are poor on these sets, but judging from your post, you didn't watch the series during its run on Comedy Central, and maybe that's influencing your opinion...? No offense, but I'd much rather pop in a DVD of material that's otherwise unvailable vs. something I can see every Saturday morning.
 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
55,912
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
I have a question....

There was a film I saw on the afternoon movie
as a kid.

It was about an astronaut that crash lands on
what he believes to be earth. The storyline is
close to Journey to the far side of the sun,
but here he meets an elderly man who needs to take
insulin injections. At the end, he looks up at
the sky and is dismayed to find two moons, now
realizing he is not on Earth.

I ask about this film because someone told me it
is a film that was spoofed on MST3K.

Anyone know of it?
 

Mark Zimmer

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jun 30, 1997
Messages
4,305
Do any MSTies out there know why there are separate shorts discs? Is this an indication that the features that these shorts went with originally are unavailable for release on DVD in an intact form? Or can we anticipate Rhino will be double-dipping and releasing the shorts in context of the full original shows too?

While season sets are a complete impossibility, at least Rhino has stepped up the speed of releases so that there's a steady flow of MST goodness at our doorsteps.
 

Jeff Kleist

Executive Producer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 4, 1999
Messages
11,267
Mark, I assume that if they can get the rights to some of these films they will, but for the most part Shorts are just the best shorts they've done (and in the public domain), and yes many of them fall into the "no way in hell" catagory
 

Christopher Bosley

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Aug 2, 1999
Messages
101
Stranded In Space it is indeed, the first ever MST3K I ever saw. Needless to say, so damn funny I nearly pissed myself and was hooked thereafter. Haven't kept up with the DVD's b/c I taped quite a few though I may now try to with this box set (worth it alone for the shorts I imagine).
 

Ronald Epstein

Founder
Owner
Joined
Jul 3, 1997
Messages
55,912
Real Name
Ronald Epstein
That's it! Thank You. You guys are the best!

By the way....

Ever sinde I posted this review I have had feelings
of guilt.

It really was a review thrown together with very
little thought. I'm not a huge fan of MST3K,
but I did love the collection of SHORTS that Rhino
sent me.

Wish I could have done a better job on this review,
but I wasn't really intending to review this set,
that is, until fans asked that I look at the DVD.

Still think it's a great purchase. Funny stuff!
 

Todd Robertson

Second Unit
Joined
Dec 18, 2002
Messages
293
Thanks for the review Ron. I've been a huge fan of the show for years and still am very addicted. I hope they release many more dvds 'cause I'll buy them all. my fav episode is The Incredible Melting Man

I guess it's just a dream that every episode will ever be released, but man, that would be outstanding!!
 

Inspector Hammer!

Executive Producer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Mar 15, 1999
Messages
11,063
Location
Houston, Texas
Real Name
John Williamson
Ron,

if you get the chance, do yourself a favour and watch a couple of the films themselves, you'll have a whale of a time!


I look foreward to Saturday mornings every week so that I can catch the show on the Sci-Fi channel, it's just too bad that they only have a select few episodes that they keep rotating over and over again, I would LOVE to see some of the old classics with Joel!


Sean,

Soultaker was on this past weekend, the boys constant ripping on poor Joe Estevez had me rolling!!


One choice moment from Soultaker

Setting is in an elevator...

(in the film)
Natalie...
"Where are you taking me!?"

Joe Estevez...
"The seventh floor Natalie."

Natalie...
"But there is no seventh floor!"

Joe Estevez...
"Their is where I come from Natalie."

Mike Nelson in response...
"So he comes from a taller building then."

 

Jeff Kleist

Executive Producer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 4, 1999
Messages
11,267
MSTie was in syndication for one season, then withdrawn over legal rights to a bunch of the films (basically only licensed for use on CC)
 

Doug Fogle

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Aug 15, 2002
Messages
94
It is definitely an addiction.I remember watching the whole turkey day marathons on CC.The only bad part was going thru withdrawal the next day.
 

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

Threads
344,173
Messages
4,702,237
Members
141,185
Latest member
dardardk