Jimbo64
Senior HTF Member
I had the box R&H set and each DVD had a second disc but the second disc of State Fair was the 1972 CinemaScope version, not the one from the 30s
I'm in for all five titles.
I've never really understood the hatred for the 1962 STATE FAIR, other than it was not right for the times in 1962. To me, it's a "fair" CinemaScope remake of the '45 version. Of course, the 1933 non-musical with Will Rogers, Janet Gaynor and Sally Eilers is the one that's the classic. But for all its faults, and there are quite a few (Tom Ewell singing to the hog, etc.) the 1962 version made a few improvements on the '45 version, which, to me, did not evoke Iowa at all, with all the outdoors on a soundstage and the Hollywood-fake farmhouse. Here, the location work really evokes the new Texas setting tremendously. Pat Boone is much more believable as a farmboy than Dick Haymes. And Ann-Margret is perfect as the girl, who, while not necessarily a "bad girl" has clearly been around a lot more than Pat's character. The DVD was looked and sounded nice, so I'm really looking forward to seeing this on Blu.
I was referring to the 1945 version which is in the BD box set of R&H musicals. Sorry for any confusion.Are you absolutely sure about that? I can't find that the 1933 version of State Fair has ever been released on DVD. It would be odd to be included in a R&H box as R&H had nothing to do with that version.
* perhaps you are confusing it with the Carousel Blu-ray which contains a standard definition copy of Liliom?
Nothing against the Sherman Bros. personally, but am I the only one here who thinks they pretty much wrote mediocre, highly-forgettable songs for most of their movies and yet, miraculously, composed a single brilliant score with MARY POPPINS? I believe an artist deserves to be judged upon his or her (or their) best work, and had they only written POPPINS, their legacy would be cemented. Their prior and subsequent work was hit or miss -- mostly miss IMHO -- with one good song here and one there. But with POPPINS, they were truly inspired, and very nearly every song was a classic. I say, good for you, Robert and Richard...amazing stuff. Sorry I can't work up much enthusiasm for most of the rest of their filmography (although I do like "Hush A Bye Mountain" from CHITTY CHITTY BANG BANG).
Flame barrier in place.
Definitely in for this one to round out my initial R&H collection which started with the first R&H Blu set. Later added the DVD for the 1964 live-action version of Cinderella.
Now in glistening 1080p: the unjustly neglected Cinemascope remake of the beloved musical about a family’s comic and romantic entanglements while visiting their annual state fair, enhancing the 1945 original’s key score numbers with five new songs solo-written by the composer and boasting spirited performances by older- and younger-generation stars.
RODGERS AND HAMMERSTEIN’S
STATE FAIR
Limited Edition BLU-RAY Release
Only 3,000 units available at www.twilighttimemovies.com & www.screenarchives.com
Once they are gone – they are gone!
RELEASE DATE: TUESDAY, JULY 18, 2017
“A clutch of professionals – Pat Boone, Ann-Margret, Bobby Darin, and Alice Faye – are not wanting in their efforts. They croon or belt… with understanding and feeling.” – Bosley Crowther, The New York Times
This 1962 remake of Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II’s 1945 movie musical, State Fair, stars Pat Boone and Pamela Tiffin as a pair of innocent Texas country mice who find complicated romance with, respectively, Ann-Margret and Bobby Darin at the titular big event. Alice Faye and Tom Ewell are their concerned parents. The Academy Award®-winning classic, “It Might As Well Be Spring,” and “It’s a Grand Night for Singing” are joined by five new songs with music and lyrics by Rodgers written for this remake.
The songwriting brothers who stirred Baby Boomer hearts and minds with Mary Poppins, Chitty Chitty Bang Bang and Bedknobs and Brromsticks musicalize Mark Twain’s two seminal books with cheer and grit in a double-feature boasting upmixed 5.1 Audio and a newly-recorded Richard M. Sherman Audio Commentary on Tom Sawyer. Twice the “gratifaction” on one swell hi-def Blu-ray.
Tom Sawyer &
Huckleberry Finn
Limited Edition BLU-RAY Release
Only 3,000 units available at www.twilighttimemovies.com & www.screenarchives.com
Once they are gone – they are gone!
RELEASE DATE: TUESDAY, JULY 18, 2017
“[Tom Sawyer is] an unpretentious and cheerful movie that uses its music well…very fetching…the best thing in its line since Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory.” – Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
“[Huckleberry Finn’s] Paul Winfield merits praise for a strong, dignified performance as Jim…Harvey Korman as the King and David Wayne as the Duke [are] an irresistible pair of rogues.”
– Lawrence Van Gelder, The New York Times
Sibling songwriting duo Richard M. Sherman and Robert B. Sherman (the men responsible for the immortal Mary Poppins) bring us a pair of musical Mark Twain adaptations: Tom Sawyer (1973), a light-hearted look at life along the Mississippi, and the more serious Huckleberry Finn (1974), which touches (more lightly here, of course, than in the original) on the subject of race in America. Acting honors in Tom Sawyer go to vets Celeste Holm and Warren Oates, and to little Johnny Whitaker and a very young Jodie Foster; in Huckleberry Finn, adolescent Jeff East is paired with the great Paul Winfield.
Nice to hear there's a Sherman commentary on SAWYER, but I see no mention of the rumored Bruce Kimmel track(s),
Special Features: Isolated Music Tracks / Tom Sawyer Audio Commentary with Screenwriter/Songwriter Richard M. Sherman and Music Producer/Historian Bruce Kimmel / Tom Sawyer Audio Commentary with Director Don Taylor, Screenwriter/Songwriter Robert B. Sherman, and Screenwriter/Songwriter Richard M. Sherman / Tom Sawyer River Song Featurette / Tom Sawyer Rehearsal with John Williams and the Sherman Brothers / Original Theatrical Trailers
I'm glad someone else noticed that Huck was duller. I doubt Kovacs would have approved (Laslo V. not Ernie ... Though Ernie was apparently a perfectionist) of the transfer. ...I just received my Sawyer/Finn disc and have sampled the quality. Tom Sawyer looks great with strong color and a nice sharp image. Huckleberry Finn a bit less with a somewhat duller image and a few specks here and there. The 5.1 soundtrack on Sawyer sounds marvelous. It's full, rich and lots of low end to give the orchestra real oomph. Only the dialog is slightly lacking most likely due to the inferior boom-mike technology of the day. The original mix, in 4.0, is not nearly as rich and I would wholeheartedly recommend the enhanced 5.1 mix. The soundtrack on Huckleberry Finn is still 2.0 stereo, but sounds just fine in Dolby Pro-logic mode.
I'm going to have to rip the commentary tracks to my computer so I can listen to them on my devices as I prefer not to watch the film while listening to commentary.