Ok, so I know that HTIB isn't great, but my Dad's Dvd player broke and he's on a *serious* budget right now. He isn't going to know good from bad when it comes to a surround sound kit, but then again I don't want to reccommend something that sounds tinny and really bad, and so i've narrowed it down to 2. All i really want to know is whether these sets will be tinny because they are 850 watts rms, and not that expensive. Because I know 850 sounds great, but if it's tinny that's no good. If you think a lesser wattage will be better, or if you think this will do the job (remember, he's going to happy if when we play a dvd he can hear explosions and bullets coming from the rear speakers with a bit of bass) could you please give me your advice. here are the players: http://www.comet.co.uk/comet/html/cache/483_317047.html http://www.comet.co.uk/comet/html/cache/483_323888.html You can scroll down to see the specs, Thanks a lot.