Matthew Brown
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Sep 19, 1999
- Messages
- 781
I didn't see this mentioned here so here is a link to a review by Matt Stevens.
http://www.loveandbullets.com/policestory2.htm
There is a controversy brewing over the aspect ratio. The image seems to be cropped up to 20% but HKL says it shouldn't be any more than 2% due to the damaged film source. The review will be updated when HKL replies to Matt.
This leads to a very interesting question. What happens when the best version of a movie just isn't good enough? In most cases, you could just wait until a proper release is done. In the case of these Hong Kong Films, a lot of effort is put into producing what we get from HKL. It's not so easy for them to just go ahead and make a new version. While miles ahead of any import and most domestic releases, HKL still isn't always perfect. The aspect ratio of HKL's MAGNIFICENT WARRIRORS has been also put into question. Also POLICE STORY is ever so slightly slightly "squashed". MAGNIFICENT BUTCHER also has this problem.
Matt
http://www.loveandbullets.com/policestory2.htm
There is a controversy brewing over the aspect ratio. The image seems to be cropped up to 20% but HKL says it shouldn't be any more than 2% due to the damaged film source. The review will be updated when HKL replies to Matt.
This leads to a very interesting question. What happens when the best version of a movie just isn't good enough? In most cases, you could just wait until a proper release is done. In the case of these Hong Kong Films, a lot of effort is put into producing what we get from HKL. It's not so easy for them to just go ahead and make a new version. While miles ahead of any import and most domestic releases, HKL still isn't always perfect. The aspect ratio of HKL's MAGNIFICENT WARRIRORS has been also put into question. Also POLICE STORY is ever so slightly slightly "squashed". MAGNIFICENT BUTCHER also has this problem.
Matt