peter m. wilson
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2002
- Messages
- 218
Hi
If there are any Marvin Gaye fans who have access to both the Tamla sacd procuded by MG and Ed Townsend "Lets Get It On" and the dvd-a Motown Records "The Marvin Gaye Collection" please comment.
My Impression is that the dvd-a has much more detail combined with a greater "you are there" feel to it".
There are a couple of songs that these discs share which I A/B'd seconds apart since my reciever has 2 sets of analogs and is what contibutes to my impression.
I would have a much more enlightened opinion if both were played in the same machine.
Both my players are entry level with the dvd-a being a JVC fa92sl and the sacd a Sony DVP-NC650v and I had never had the exact songs in both formats before.
Please don't get the impression that I'm saying one format is better than another this is a disc not a format discussion, I have over 170 discs in the combination of formats and thorughly enjoy them both.
Peter m.
If there are any Marvin Gaye fans who have access to both the Tamla sacd procuded by MG and Ed Townsend "Lets Get It On" and the dvd-a Motown Records "The Marvin Gaye Collection" please comment.
My Impression is that the dvd-a has much more detail combined with a greater "you are there" feel to it".
There are a couple of songs that these discs share which I A/B'd seconds apart since my reciever has 2 sets of analogs and is what contibutes to my impression.
I would have a much more enlightened opinion if both were played in the same machine.
Both my players are entry level with the dvd-a being a JVC fa92sl and the sacd a Sony DVP-NC650v and I had never had the exact songs in both formats before.
Please don't get the impression that I'm saying one format is better than another this is a disc not a format discussion, I have over 170 discs in the combination of formats and thorughly enjoy them both.
Peter m.