What's new

Hulu Broadcast TV High Potential (ABC) (1 Viewer)

Adam Lenhardt

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2001
Messages
27,793
Location
Albany, NY
Drew Goddard (The Cabin in the Woods, The Martian, Bad Times at the El Royale) tries his hand at a police procedural with this American adaptation of the French series "HPI: Haut potentiel intellectuel", which also counted Rob Thomas ("Veronica Mars", "Party Down", "iZombie") among its executive producers for its initial run of episodes, with Todd Harthan ("The Resident") taking over for the remainder of the first season.

Morgan is a cleaning lady with three children ranging from infant to early teens from two exes, series issues with authority, and no car. Her life is a mess. But she also has an IQ of 160, a Sherlock Holmes-like aptitude for observation, and a photographic memory full of obscure information.

One night, working her night shifty cleaning the police station, she accidentally knocks a box of evidence off of a detective's desk. While putting it back together, she notices a key piece of evidence that the investigators missed. With a prominent lawyer missing and a killer on the loose, the lieutenant in charge of homicides (Judy Reyes from "Scrubs") entices her to consult on the case.

Along with "Elsbeth" and "Will Trent", this feels like a throwback to the character-driven procedurals like "Columbo" and the shows that USA Network used to excel at like "Monk" and "Psych", only edgier.

It's nice to see Kaitlin Olson get a role that utilizes her full range of talents, getting to be as crass like Sweet Dee in "Always Sunny" at times while also being plausible as a genius-level intellect.

The lead detective makes for a nice foil; while he misses things that Morgan catches, he also reins her in a bit and better understands that building a criminal case requires following proper procedures. Some of the most compelling scenes in the pilot come where Morgan and the detective leverage each other's strengths to make breakthroughs.

Her home life is eventful enough to have its own story lines. She has recently split up with the father of her youngest two children, an unambitious driving instructor with the patience of a saint. Her son, the middle child, shares her intellectual prowess and the quirks that come with them. Her oldest daughter is smart too, but much more of a conventional thinker.

While the structure is built around the case of the week that gets solved by the end of the hour, there's also a through line with the father of Morgan's eldest daughter, who vanished without a trace years earlier. Morgan only agrees to consult with the police going forward in exchange for help solving his disappearance. One gets the sense that he was the love of her life. But her compulsive personality also makes the lack of answers unbearable, and she hates that her eldest thinks her father abandoned her.
 

thejohnwatson

Auditioning
Joined
Sep 18, 2024
Messages
3
Real Name
John Watson
Adam, I appreciate your detailed breakdown of the show, but I feel the concept might struggle to stand out. The idea of a messy, genius consultant solving cases has been done quite often, as seen in shows like Monk and Sherlock. While Morgan's character sounds promising, especially with her personal struggles and unique dynamics with the detective, the show risks falling into a predictable pattern. I’m curious to see if they can bring something fresh to the table beyond the standard "case of the week" format.
 

mskaye

Patron
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2021
Messages
2,432
Location
USA
Real Name
Michael Kochman
Adam, I appreciate your detailed breakdown of the show, but I feel the concept might struggle to stand out. The idea of a messy, genius consultant solving cases has been done quite often, as seen in shows like Monk and Sherlock. While Morgan's character sounds promising, especially with her personal struggles and unique dynamics with the detective, the show risks falling into a predictable pattern. I’m curious to see if they can bring something fresh to the table beyond the standard "case of the week" format.
I wonder if they are going after the success of Peacock's Poker Face crowd with this. Intuitive crime solvers (though it seems too weighed down by network tv bs and tropes.) Poker Face because it is on Peacock is delightfully "adult" and while it's very very indebted to Columbo is very much its own thing. I highly recommend that show.
 

Dennis_H

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Apr 5, 2001
Messages
146
Poker Face was one of my top 2 or 3 shows over the last couple years. I'll resub to Peacock when it comes back after letting that lapse for the big price increase...
 

mskaye

Patron
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2021
Messages
2,432
Location
USA
Real Name
Michael Kochman
Poker Face was one of my top 2 or 3 shows over the last couple years. I'll resub to Peacock when it comes back after letting that lapse for the big price increase...
Ditto.
 

Adam Lenhardt

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2001
Messages
27,793
Location
Albany, NY
I wonder if they are going after the success of Peacock's Poker Face crowd with this. Intuitive crime solvers (though it seems too weighed down by network tv bs and tropes.) Poker Face because it is on Peacock is delightfully "adult" and while it's very very indebted to Columbo is very much its own thing. I highly recommend that show.
There are definitely some similarities to "Poker Face", particularly with a down and out female protagonist with a special set of skills. But Charlie Cale, in addition to being played by Natasha Lyonne, is a very Natasha Lyonne-esque character: eccentric in a way that feels specifically New York City Jewish, but also strangely laid back and detached. And the nature of Charlie's predicament is such that she's living a transient lifestyle, owing as much of a debt to Richard Kimble in "The Fugitive" as Columbo. Some people just kind of float through life, and Charlie Cale is one of them.

Morgan on this show is a single mother of three children, two of which are school age, so she couldn't be transient even if she wanted to, and she doesn't have the luxury of being laid back and detached. Her blunt and confrontational nature is probably a big reason why she's working as an overnight cleaning lady with such a staggeringly high IQ.
 

mskaye

Patron
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2021
Messages
2,432
Location
USA
Real Name
Michael Kochman
There are definitely some similarities to "Poker Face", particularly with a down and out female protagonist with a special set of skills. But Charlie Cale, in addition to being played by Natasha Lyonne, is a very Natasha Lyonne-esque character: eccentric in a way that feels specifically New York City Jewish, but also strangely laid back and detached. And the nature of Charlie's predicament is such that she's living a transient lifestyle, owing as much of a debt to Richard Kimble in "The Fugitive" as Columbo. Some people just kind of float through life, and Charlie Cale is one of them.

Morgan on this show is a single mother of three children, two of which are school age, so she couldn't be transient even if she wanted to, and she doesn't have the luxury of being laid back and detached. Her blunt and confrontational nature is probably a big reason why she's working as an overnight cleaning lady with such a staggeringly high IQ.
Speaking of Columbo, I really enjoy this podcast by two veteran podcasters. It's not a non-stop love fest, so beware of some hot takes on what worked and what didn't from time to time but overall very enjoyable.
 

thejohnwatson

Auditioning
Joined
Sep 18, 2024
Messages
3
Real Name
John Watson
I wonder if they are going after the success of Peacock's Poker Face crowd with this. Intuitive crime solvers (though it seems too weighed down by network tv bs and tropes.) Poker Face because it is on Peacock is delightfully "adult" and while it's very very indebted to Columbo is very much its own thing. I highly recommend that show.
mskaye, I completely get where you're coming from. "Poker Face" indeed has a distinct edge, mainly because it's free from the typical network constraints and, as you pointed out, stays true to its "adult" tone. It's refreshing to see something like that thrive, especially when it manages to feel original despite its clear nods to Columbo. The freedom platforms like Peacock provide definitely allows for more creative risks, which often translates to stronger character development and less reliance on overused tropes.

However, with this adaptation, I feel like it's walking a tightrope—trying to tap into the success of shows like "Monk" or even "Sherlock", but could easily get bogged down by predictable patterns if it leans too heavily on procedural formulas. I just hope they find a way to bring that same freshness to network TV, though it might be a bit challenging. Let's see if they can surprise us or if it’ll turn out to be just another formulaic crime solver drama.
 

mskaye

Patron
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2021
Messages
2,432
Location
USA
Real Name
Michael Kochman
mskaye, I completely get where you're coming from. "Poker Face" indeed has a distinct edge, mainly because it's free from the typical network constraints and, as you pointed out, stays true to its "adult" tone. It's refreshing to see something like that thrive, especially when it manages to feel original despite its clear nods to Columbo. The freedom platforms like Peacock provide definitely allows for more creative risks, which often translates to stronger character development and less reliance on overused tropes.

However, with this adaptation, I feel like it's walking a tightrope—trying to tap into the success of shows like "Monk" or even "Sherlock", but could easily get bogged down by predictable patterns if it leans too heavily on procedural formulas. I just hope they find a way to bring that same freshness to network TV, though it might be a bit challenging. Let's see if they can surprise us or if it’ll turn out to be just another formulaic crime solver drama.
What elevates Poker Face is the unique presence of Natasha, the direction, and the great casting. Not many shows have a real feature film quality bona fide director like Rian J at the helm. Look, it’s been one season and it was supremely enjoyable. I’d be happy just for that but admittedly I’d like to see more.
 

David Weicker

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2005
Messages
4,799
Real Name
David
Can the discussion about Poker Face be moved to another thread.

Less than half of these posts are about High Potential
 

TonyD

Who do I think I am, anyway?
Ambassador
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 1, 1999
Messages
24,681
Location
Trying to figure that out
Real Name
Tony D.
Speaking of Columbo, I really enjoy this podcast by two veteran podcasters. It's not a non-stop love fest, so beware of some hot takes on what worked and what didn't from time to time but overall very enjoyable.


First ep was just kjind of okay.
Trying a little too hard to be quirky or give her idiosyncratic behaviors.

This was more like Monk and Elsbeth then columbo or poker face but without the charm of those people.


That podcast is really good for fans of columbo
 

NeilO

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2002
Messages
4,714
From a Deadline article:
The network has been able to increase High Potential’s episode count by a couple of hours from last season’s 13-episode order, which will stretch its sophomore run into midseason.

“We have so much momentum going with that show, and I actually think it will perform even better next year,” Erwich said, noting the additional exposure High Potential‘s first season has been getting on Hulu as well as ABC though reruns.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top