HDTV or 36" Analog TV (1 Viewer)

[Mark Johnson]

Ive been reading this forum for awhile, but havent posted anything. Just want to say thanks for all the valuable info
Anyways my question is I have a family room that is about 11 from the TV. I have read that the optimal distance for 36 is I think 11 feet.
My dilemma is that I dont wether to get a 32' HDTV Samsung or a 36' analog tv (looking at Sony,Toshiba) which will be in my price range...$1400.00
Will the extra four inches make a big difference or should I go with the better picture (HDTV)
Any suggestions will be appriciated. Right now Im leaning towards the HDTV because of my Xbox.

 

[Matt Stone]

Are you married to direct view? I only ask because the 47" Panny Rear Projection HDTV can be had for ~1400.

 

[Mark Johnson]

No, But where my TV sets is only 47" W x 58" D x 24", Depth is what really a factor as when I look for a 36" analog it usually about a inche too long.

Ill check out that panasonic, but Im sure it wont fit.

Does a 36" make a big difference for the distance I will be watching? Or would it be best to get the last technology ir HDTV (samsung)?

 

[Matt Stone]

Are you saying that it can only be 24" tall?
36" IMO is a tad to small at 11 feet. In fact, it's too small for me at 9 feet.
Check out the viewing distance calculator at:
http://www.myhometheater.homestead.c...alculator.html
I'd personally go HD...

 

[Jack Briggs]

Always go for the better picture quality over screen real estate. At the price range you're considering, get the latest technology--not a big set that's NTSC-only.

 

[Arthur S]

I hate to disagree with Jack Briggs, however, from 11 feet the larger picture will have much more impact than the HD capability on a 32 inch set. You can get a good 36 inch tube for $700 from SAMS Club, BJs, and other places as well.

If you were going to be sitting closer, a HD ready TV would be better to eliminate the horizontal scanning lines.

Arte

 

[Jack Briggs]

Arthur, you're allowed to disagree with me sir! Mark needs more than one opinion.

 

[Mark Johnson]

Thanks guys! More opinons is always good! Except for someone living in LA...Ya beat my Kings! j/k


Im really at a empasse deciding between a 36 analog and a 32'HDTV.