BenG
Agent
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2001
- Messages
- 27
My previous setup:
Optimus PRO-CS5 center channel (Linaeum dipole ribbon tweeter)
2 Optimus LX-5 surrounds (Linaeum dipole ribbon)
2 Optimus LX-10 towers (long-discontinued tower versions of the LX5's, same tweeters)
SVS 20-39PC
This is a quite inexpensive, overall well-performing matchup, but the timbre-matching between the center, the fronts, and the surrounds left much to be desired. And I have always been disappointed in the midrange for music playback (using the two LX10's in stereo)
Looking to replace the speakers (not the sub though ), I began looking around for some good bookshelf speakers that would improve on these two weaknesses, and not set me back a heck of a lot of money. I figured that towers were probably a waste of money, with the SVS 20-39 quaking my apartment at one-quarter volume After reading many hearty approvals on this forum, I picked the JBL NSP-1 set (one N-Center and four N-24's) for $299.
This is definitely a decent surround setup (for the money!). The midrange is incredibly better, and the overall sound is clearer and more well-defined. The highs arent bad, but are nothing to rave about. What is bothering me is how totally "boxy" these speakers sound compared to my old setup. I suppose it is just my ears not used to hearing a non-ribbon tweeter, but I cant get over that I'm listening to "speakers playing music" rather than just "music", even if the sound is more accurate. Watching a few DVDs also left me feeling like I just invested $300 on a downgrade, rather than an upgrade
Does anyone have experience going from ribbon/dipole setup to a dome-tweeter based setup, or have any suggestions on other speakers that might be better? Or am I making no sense? There arent enough words in the thesaurus to describe a financially-challenged audiophile's frustration :frowning:
Optimus PRO-CS5 center channel (Linaeum dipole ribbon tweeter)
2 Optimus LX-5 surrounds (Linaeum dipole ribbon)
2 Optimus LX-10 towers (long-discontinued tower versions of the LX5's, same tweeters)
SVS 20-39PC
This is a quite inexpensive, overall well-performing matchup, but the timbre-matching between the center, the fronts, and the surrounds left much to be desired. And I have always been disappointed in the midrange for music playback (using the two LX10's in stereo)
Looking to replace the speakers (not the sub though ), I began looking around for some good bookshelf speakers that would improve on these two weaknesses, and not set me back a heck of a lot of money. I figured that towers were probably a waste of money, with the SVS 20-39 quaking my apartment at one-quarter volume After reading many hearty approvals on this forum, I picked the JBL NSP-1 set (one N-Center and four N-24's) for $299.
This is definitely a decent surround setup (for the money!). The midrange is incredibly better, and the overall sound is clearer and more well-defined. The highs arent bad, but are nothing to rave about. What is bothering me is how totally "boxy" these speakers sound compared to my old setup. I suppose it is just my ears not used to hearing a non-ribbon tweeter, but I cant get over that I'm listening to "speakers playing music" rather than just "music", even if the sound is more accurate. Watching a few DVDs also left me feeling like I just invested $300 on a downgrade, rather than an upgrade
Does anyone have experience going from ribbon/dipole setup to a dome-tweeter based setup, or have any suggestions on other speakers that might be better? Or am I making no sense? There arent enough words in the thesaurus to describe a financially-challenged audiophile's frustration :frowning: