Kenneth
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Jul 31, 1997
- Messages
- 757
Since the other thread has primarily focussed on getting the new Harry Potter book I thought I would risk separate thread to discuss the novel so those still pricing it or discussing different versions don't need to worry about bleed through discussion.
After completing the 6th book I think JK Rowling has set up a pretty tremendious undertaking for the 7th to wrap things up. The death of
Dumbledore has now put HP in the lead position for the final conflict with Voldemort
However, with the introduction of the
Horcruxes there are now 4 quests leading up to the final confrontation with Voldemort. Five major events in one book seems a little overpowering.
My preference, since she has hinted at the 8th book, rather than trying to wrap things up in one more try she should split the final confrontation into two volumes. In the 7th book she could
deal with the question of the horcruxes, which if done right could easily take an entire book. She could also expand on the Malfoy or Snape threads that both changed in book 6
This would leave book 8 clear to address the final confrontation with Voldemort. As much as I would love to see things wrapped in the next book, I think it could become over 1000 pages if she doesn't shortchange things.
What does everyone else think?
Kenneth
After completing the 6th book I think JK Rowling has set up a pretty tremendious undertaking for the 7th to wrap things up. The death of
Dumbledore has now put HP in the lead position for the final conflict with Voldemort
However, with the introduction of the
Horcruxes there are now 4 quests leading up to the final confrontation with Voldemort. Five major events in one book seems a little overpowering.
My preference, since she has hinted at the 8th book, rather than trying to wrap things up in one more try she should split the final confrontation into two volumes. In the 7th book she could
deal with the question of the horcruxes, which if done right could easily take an entire book. She could also expand on the Malfoy or Snape threads that both changed in book 6
This would leave book 8 clear to address the final confrontation with Voldemort. As much as I would love to see things wrapped in the next book, I think it could become over 1000 pages if she doesn't shortchange things.
What does everyone else think?
Kenneth