Our buddies over at The Digital Bits have some info about what to do if you have a defective Godfather Bonus disc. http://www.thedigitalbits.com/#godfatherexchange "We've spoken to Paramount on behalf of all those of you who report having trouble with your Bonus Disc from the studio's Godfather DVD Collection. The studio will be happy to exchange the defective discs for new ones. To receive a replacement, mail your disc (and only the disc) in a jewel case to: Liz Haggar Paramount Home Entertainment 5555 Melrose Avenue Hollywood CA 90038. If you have any questions, you may call the consumer hotline at 323-956-8070. "