What's new

Embarrasing Mistake in TNG Season 1 Set (1 Viewer)

David Williams

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2001
Messages
2,288
Real Name
David Williams
I searched the forums, hopefully I haven't missed it, but it seems to have gone unnoticed... In the insert for the First Season it lists the characters. Everyone's favorite stud muffin has been given a demotion to Lt. Cmdr. William T. Riker! It also neglects to mention Data, Dr. Crusher, and Counselor Troi's rank, even though everyone else gets a rank before their name, with the exception of Wesley. (For the record, that's 2 Lt. Cmdrs and 1 Cmdr)
 

Jeff Kleist

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 4, 1999
Messages
11,267
So far as I know, it's similar to the "Commodore" rank for Captains. Since he is the Senior Lt. Commander on board, he's referred to as "commander". His pips are different because he's the first officer. When Sisko took command of DS9 he was a Lt. Commander(referred to as "Commander")and was only much later promoted to Captain.
 

Josh Dial

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2000
Messages
4,216
Real Name
Josh Dial
Jeff, I must disagree with you on this notion.

I'm pretty sure the credits list him as Commander. Though it is true lt.comm is called "commander" though I'm sure its purely for brevity.

Data is a lt.comm and referred to as commander in this fashion.

Since I believe you cannot be promoted "past" a rank, as in being a lt.comm then becoming a Captain, I would say Riker is a commander (3 pips). Since Riker turned down his commission of Captain to serve as the first officer on the flag ship.

Lastly (this is too damn long eh?) in the episode where the crew looses the long term memories/identities...the computer manifest lists riker and a commander.

Probably a misprint. OR Riker was silently promoted ala LaForge during the "off season"

cheers!

Josh
 

Mike Broadman

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2001
Messages
4,951
To the best of my knowledge, there is no such rank called "commander." Ranks are things like lieutenants, colonels, captains, etc. They can be hyphenated with modifiers, like Lt.-Commander.

So, if I'm right, Riker's formal rank is indeed Lieutenant-Commander. He "outranks" Data because of his role on the ship, not because of the rank titles. The "commander" part only signifies that the officer has permanent crew command responsbilities, as shown in the episode where Troi applies to get promoted so that she can command the night crew.

If Riker's rank is listed as just "commander," it's probably just to shorten it up. "Commander" implies "Lt-Commander," because there is no other kind of commander.
 

David Williams

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2001
Messages
2,288
Real Name
David Williams
Just to clarify this: William Thomas Riker has and continues to be, for more than 15 years, (and until Star Trek: Nemesis comes out) a full Commander, not a Lieutenant Commander. :) Check with Startrek.com The Omnipedia, or any of the other books if you have any doubts.
Riker turned down command of U.S.S. Drake to serve as First Officer. The Drake went to Paul Rice whom Riker bumps into, or at least a robot pretending to be, in the first season episode Arsenal of Freedom. He served as Captain Robert DeSoto's First Officer on the U.S.S. Hood before coming to the Enterprise.
Ben Sisko was also a Commander, serving as First Officer on the U.S.S. Saratoga and a side trip at Utopia Planitia, before being promoted in the 4th or 5th season of DS9 to Captain.
On most Federation ships, the First Officer almost always carries the rank of full Commander.
Star Trek ranks go as follows (more or less following Naval fashion):
Admiral (4 different flavors): up to 4 full pips with a bar around it
Captain: 4 full pips
Commander: 3 full pips
Lieutenant Commander: 2 full pips, 1 empty pip
Lieutenant: 2 full pips
Lieutenant Junior Grade (J.G.): 1 full pip, 1 empty pip
Ensign: 1 full pip
Chief Petty Officer: 1 empty pip
Trekkers being the fanatical bunch we are, are going to notice this like it had a huge neon sign pointing to it.
 

David Lambert

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
11,377
Agreement with the last three entries. I know for a fact that Riker was full Commander from day 1, and when everyone views the episodes they will see that this is correct. He was already past the Lt.-Commander stage when we meet him at Farpoint.
This is a major oversight in the creation of this insert, which I actually hadn't read yet...just admired the full-spread artwork of! :)
Congratulations to all of us who have this insert! Since Paramount will surely correct it very soon, we probably have a genuine collector's item on our hands! :D
 

DougWright

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Mar 24, 2000
Messages
155
Anyone else notice that when we first get to the bridge in "encounter at farpoint" data is stretching/cracking his finger knuckles. Then starts to "type" on his terminal.

Was he lubricating? I am gonna watch for further instances of this in later episodes, but I had not seen it before. Seems like soemthing an android would not need to do.
 

David Lambert

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
11,377
This instance of Data cracking his knuckles was pointed out by nitpickers a looooong time ago! :)
The "official" explanation is that Data was trying to emulate human characteristics, and often did "human" things that an android would not NEED to do.
And THAT behavior - of trying to duplicate human mannerisms - is definately repeated throughout all 7 seasons of TNG...and even into the films!
EDIT: Whoops! Shayne's brief response beat my long-winded response by just a few seconds! :laugh:
 

JonZ

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Dec 28, 1998
Messages
7,799
Doug,
He was probally just imitating something hes seen humans do over and over again. (yup Shane and Dave beat me to it)
I cant remember the episode name, but one of my favorite Data moments was him watching and imitating Riker shake hands and introduce himself to a Admiral at a party.(Loved the raised eyebrow, false smile and handshake)(The episode where Picard went back for his horse saddle and got stranded abord the Enterpise with some terrorists)
Ok, Ive slipped, 4 years ago I couldve remembered the name of the episode easily.:frowning:
 

Britton

Screenwriter
Joined
Jun 3, 2001
Messages
1,102
To the best of my knowledge said:
The episode you refer to is Starship Mine from the Sixth Season. It was basically Die Hard on the Enterprise with Picard in the John McClane role. Data was trying to master the art of small talk (after failing miserably to engage in the act with Picard), which Commander Hutchinson was a master at.
 

Jack Briggs

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jun 3, 1999
Messages
16,805
You know, here it is on a Wednesday, and my set still hasn't arrived. I have not looked forward to many DVD arrivals as much as this one. Damn.
 

Shayne Lebrun

Screenwriter
Joined
Jun 17, 1999
Messages
1,086
Call me Hutch!

Seems like everyone is an officer or non-comm in the Trek world. There any enlisted folk on board?

The Original Series had non-coms. On TNG and above, you needed to go through Starfleet Academy before you could get a starship posting, I believe.

Makes sense, too, considering the length of some of the missions.
 

David Williams

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2001
Messages
2,288
Real Name
David Williams
Actually, Chief O'Brien, was, I believe a Chief Warrant Officer, not an enlisted Chief Petty Officer.
Miles is definitely a Chief Petty Officer (1 empty pip). Confirmation comes in the TNG 4th season ep, "Family" when Mr. O'Brien is introduced to Helena & Sergey Rozhenko (Worf's Parents) and Sergey comments that O'Brien is a Chief Petty Officer just like he was.
There were noncoms on TNG (Crewman Simon Tarses springs to mind) and O'Brien had a bunch of them working under him on DS9 in later seasons. There are no noncomm Starfleet Academy grads though... automatic Ensigns upon graduation. Starfleet does offer training schools, though, for those who wish to serve without going through the Academy.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

Threads
352,000
Messages
4,971,966
Members
143,170
Latest member
CrossAtlantic
Recent bookmarks
0
Top