Elias
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2002
- Messages
- 52
I thought I would take a moment to describe my experience with the DVD connection to my new Samsung HLN617W DLP TV. Briefly, I recommend that the DVD player Progressive Scan feature is set to OFF for optimum viewing on the HLN series.
I bought a Panasonic RP-82 player a few months ago specifically because it was highly praised for its Progressive Scan technology, anticipating that high-quality video signals would be a must for the 61 inch Samsung DLP TV, which I received two weeks ago.
I initially connected my RP-82 to the Component 1 input on the TV (this is the DVD input that accepts 480i and 480p) and turned the RP-82 Progressive Scan feature ON, sending a 480p signal to the TV input. I noticed two problems when viewing DVD signals in this fashion. The first problem was that the image was extremely dark on the TV such that many details in dark scenes could not be discerned from the background (I refer you to the scene in the rain when Kirstin Dunst is attacked by thugs). This problem could not be significantly corrected by increasing the brightness on the DVD component video output (the RP-82 allows you to toggle between a lighter and darker picture; this setting is actually supposed to be on 'darker' when connecting to bright DLP and plasma TVs). Furthermore, even with the 'lighter' picture coming out of the DVD player, I could not correct the problem using the brightest picture mode on the DLP TV (Dynamic). The second problem is that the color of the picture was off, biasing toward green colors. This was especially apparent in The Matrix, where half the movie (all scenes taking place in the Matrix itself) is filmed in a washed out greenish/grey color. These scenes appeared abnormally green (and dark)using my DVD player's Progressive Scan output (take a look at the scene when Agent Smith first meets Neo in the office). Both problems remain unchanged when the signal is sent to the other TV inputs (Component 2 and 3).
It appears that I was not alone in noting deficiencies with this connection method. Several people on this site have voiced their opinion that the picture looks much better when the progressive scan feature is OFF on the DVD player, and a 480i signal is sent to the Samsung DLP. I was utterly surprised to hear this, since the RP-82 is so highly praised for its Progressive Scan capabilities. I also assumed that the TV would be inferior to the RP-82 in deinterlacing technology. On the contrary, the DCDi chip on the Samsung DLP TV is quite good and does better progressive scan conversion than the RP-82 chip.
I therefore went ahead and disabled the Progressive Scan on the DVD player (necessitating connection to the Component 1 input, which is the only input accepting 480i signals) and immediately noted correction of both problems. The image was much brighter, with greater detail in dark scenes, and the annoying greenish tint was gone. I did notice, however, that the background in dark scenes was on the gray side (as opposed to black). I guess DLP TVs are known for this black-level problem. I decided that I needed to bring the brightness down on either my DVD player or on my TV. I experimented with both of these methods and noticed that details were unacceptably lost with my DVD player in the 'darker' picture mode. I ultimately created a custom setting on the TV which seems to be the best compromise of detail vs. black-level in dark scenes. I will be happy to share my settings, which are similar to the 'Movie' mode with some modifications:
--Custom settings for DVD movies using 480i output
(RP-82 output set to 'lighter,' with Progressive OFF)
Contrast: 80
Brightness: 45
Sharpness: 75
Color: 60
Tint: bar is half red and half green
I hope this thread will serve not only to make people aware of this issue, but also to get others' opinions as to the optimum TV picture settings for viewing DVDs on the Samsung HLN DLP TV series. I am willing to bet that my settings can be much improved upon.
Elias Aliprandis
I bought a Panasonic RP-82 player a few months ago specifically because it was highly praised for its Progressive Scan technology, anticipating that high-quality video signals would be a must for the 61 inch Samsung DLP TV, which I received two weeks ago.
I initially connected my RP-82 to the Component 1 input on the TV (this is the DVD input that accepts 480i and 480p) and turned the RP-82 Progressive Scan feature ON, sending a 480p signal to the TV input. I noticed two problems when viewing DVD signals in this fashion. The first problem was that the image was extremely dark on the TV such that many details in dark scenes could not be discerned from the background (I refer you to the scene in the rain when Kirstin Dunst is attacked by thugs). This problem could not be significantly corrected by increasing the brightness on the DVD component video output (the RP-82 allows you to toggle between a lighter and darker picture; this setting is actually supposed to be on 'darker' when connecting to bright DLP and plasma TVs). Furthermore, even with the 'lighter' picture coming out of the DVD player, I could not correct the problem using the brightest picture mode on the DLP TV (Dynamic). The second problem is that the color of the picture was off, biasing toward green colors. This was especially apparent in The Matrix, where half the movie (all scenes taking place in the Matrix itself) is filmed in a washed out greenish/grey color. These scenes appeared abnormally green (and dark)using my DVD player's Progressive Scan output (take a look at the scene when Agent Smith first meets Neo in the office). Both problems remain unchanged when the signal is sent to the other TV inputs (Component 2 and 3).
It appears that I was not alone in noting deficiencies with this connection method. Several people on this site have voiced their opinion that the picture looks much better when the progressive scan feature is OFF on the DVD player, and a 480i signal is sent to the Samsung DLP. I was utterly surprised to hear this, since the RP-82 is so highly praised for its Progressive Scan capabilities. I also assumed that the TV would be inferior to the RP-82 in deinterlacing technology. On the contrary, the DCDi chip on the Samsung DLP TV is quite good and does better progressive scan conversion than the RP-82 chip.
I therefore went ahead and disabled the Progressive Scan on the DVD player (necessitating connection to the Component 1 input, which is the only input accepting 480i signals) and immediately noted correction of both problems. The image was much brighter, with greater detail in dark scenes, and the annoying greenish tint was gone. I did notice, however, that the background in dark scenes was on the gray side (as opposed to black). I guess DLP TVs are known for this black-level problem. I decided that I needed to bring the brightness down on either my DVD player or on my TV. I experimented with both of these methods and noticed that details were unacceptably lost with my DVD player in the 'darker' picture mode. I ultimately created a custom setting on the TV which seems to be the best compromise of detail vs. black-level in dark scenes. I will be happy to share my settings, which are similar to the 'Movie' mode with some modifications:
--Custom settings for DVD movies using 480i output
(RP-82 output set to 'lighter,' with Progressive OFF)
Contrast: 80
Brightness: 45
Sharpness: 75
Color: 60
Tint: bar is half red and half green
I hope this thread will serve not only to make people aware of this issue, but also to get others' opinions as to the optimum TV picture settings for viewing DVDs on the Samsung HLN DLP TV series. I am willing to bet that my settings can be much improved upon.
Elias Aliprandis